Went to Cape May for a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place was good. Service was spot on. And the flourless chocolate cake for dessert was a real treat. He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. The front patio is cozy ,warm and quiet. Many at our table had the halibut and it was absolutely delicious..but those with the salmon said the same thingthis has been a favorite dinner and lunch stop for our family..always top notch in every way!!! The waitress (I forget her name) was very pleasant and madesure everything was to our liking (it was). This was the second best restaurant if our stay. I started with the mussel appetizer which was good to the last drop and my husband started with the polenta board which I of course had to try - GREAT! $6.50 Only 1 available Connie Crawford Design Shorts and Caprud Pants, Sizes Xxl - 6X Complete Uncut/FF McCall's Sewing Pattern B5504 DaisyandErma 7,756 sales | Add to cart Arrives by Apr 19-25 if you order today. It was a great experience for both of us! The staff was also very accommodating and flexible, as they seated us outside after we had received for indoors. Debbie M. said: Originally walked up to the main entrance. Excellent!!! Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Sauce on the halibut special was amazing! mozzarella, and peas as an appetizer. Harvest Salad, Parpadella Pasta with Ragu and Salmon & Shrimp - my husband and I sharedall three then finished with coffee and tiramisuMore. Daily 4:30 pm9:00 pm, 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204. The front patio is cozy ,warm and quiet. Don't mind paying alot, but would have been nice to have a little more. Whatever your choice may be, we promise to make your experience a memorable one. Was not at all. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 0 Votes Not that I am aware. The two tables next to us likewise enjoyed their experiencesand meals and had ordered items different from ours. their "specials" are always awesome.loved the Halibut with lump crab special. We dined here recently and the food was magnificent as always. Tisha's: Delicious - See 1,764 traveller reviews, 132 candid photos, and great deals for Cape May, NJ, at Tripadvisor. It was our first one year anniversary and it was delightful. What is the dress code? Great ambience great food great services Fabulous as always. This place is famous for great juice, cappuccino or chocolate frappe. There is inside and outdoor seating which is a delight. Excellent food and service. Asked by . The truffle fries were amazing. Everything flows smooth as silkexcellent food as alwaysreally, always; great service with a smile and engagement; ambiance delightful. Good service . Excellent food and service. My husband said we should have booked all of our dinners at Tisha's. Ordered seafood / pasta special. Excellent!!! Home-> Atlantic City-> Cape May, NJ-> Contemporary American. Download. Loved it all!!! My husband said we should have booked all of our dinners at Tisha's. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. She was pleasant and competent. The chef definitely knows his way around the kitchen. We both had them this time and we were not disappointed. The food was excellent. Thai Salmon was cooked to perfection. The food was excellent, although rather pricey. From salad to desert, including the service it's a must. Everyone down there is usually on vacation and seems like a real chill environment. View information about Tisha's to help decide on what to eat. Delicious as usual! Service was great! Always an excellent meal. Are you sure you want to delete this question? Zoom in to see updated info. Alex, our waitres, was great. Great food and service! Good choice. Fantastic meal and service from start to finish. I love dining at Tisha's!! Perfect atmosphere for casual dining, fine dining or any special occasion. Come join us for such delights as Halibut topped with jumbo lump crabmeat or grilled filet Mignon topped with grilled lobster tail finished with barnaise. Tasty fries . The menu is small but the food is so fresh and amazing. Perfect atmosphere for casual dining, fine dining or any special occasion. Cant wait to come back! Went to Cape May for a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place was good. Went to Cape May for a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place was good. Nice to see Ben again after 5 years. Thank you for a wonderful evening. The food, like its Restaurant School graduate chef/owner, was genuine, unique & unforgettable. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. Been dining here for 25 years and never disappointed. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Delicious as usual! Perfect meal our waiter Daniel was terrific. Favorite spot in Cape May! Explore menu, see photos and read 5988 reviews: "We took our 11 and 8 year old's' for dinner and it was a wonderful It did not disappoint! Every time we visit Cape May, we make sure to dine at Tishas. Offerings: BYOB, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Patio Dining, Handicap Accessible, Personal wines allowed, Tisha's Dining Spaces or Locations. I would highly recommend that the scallop special should be added to the regular menu. I always got seafood risotto in the past and it is even better than I remembered! Appetizer and dinner was excellent. Cape May Carriage Company is what you should see after having a meal at Tisha's. Italian cuisine is provided at this restaurant. This was the second best restaurant if our stay. The seafood risotto was amazing and so was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream. By lowering the lights it made it difficult to read the menu and see what was on my plate. Was not at all. Two couples will be dining here together here. We likewise enjoyed the arancini. Went here for New Years! There's always next year.. Our waitress, Deanna ?? Tisha's never disappoints. We always eat here when in Cape May. Sauce on the halibut special was amazing! Everything flows smooth as silkexcellent food as alwaysreally, always; great service with a smile and engagement; ambiance delightful. An overall excellent experience at Tishas highlighted by an excellent meal, observant service and a pleasant atmosphere! The experience was wonderful. A lot of people say that waiters serve good profiteroles, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes here. By lowering the lights it made it difficult to read the menu and see what was on my plate. There's always next year.. Our waitress, Deanna ?? at reasonable prices. 322 Washington St, Cape May, New Jersey, USA. we have not been here in a very long time and it was just as wonderful as the other times! It reminds us of a fine chef George Perrier when he was in Philadelphia but for much less. Cuisines Contemporary American, Italian, Seafood Hours of Operation Dinner Mon-Fri 4:30 pm-9:00 pm Phone number (609) 884-9119 Website http://www.tishasfinedining.com/ Payment Options AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa Dress Code Casual Dress Executive Chef Paul Negro Private party contact Lauren K Vitelli: (609) 827-3140 Location He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. The halibut with crab meat is my favorite, His key lime pie was outstanding. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. Cape May Tisha's Fine Dining Tisha's Fine Dining (609) 884-9119 Own this business? their "specials" are always awesome.loved the Halibut with lump crab special. It's the best food in Cape May and worth every penny. My husband said we should have booked all of our dinners at Tisha's. Favorite spot in Cape May! Xxx bbb bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb. Veal Milanese and Filet were also amazing! The menu is small but the food is so fresh and amazing. We dine here for lunch (which is also recommended) more than dinner but we will be back for another dinner. Weve walked past Trishas many times over the years but today was the first we dined at this top notch restaurant. We got the mussels, fries, carpaccio and lobster salad without the bun all fabulous. Don't mind paying alot, but would have been nice to have a little more. BYOB and we do served wine by the bottle from Cape May Winery. The staff was also very accommodating and flexible, as they seated us outside after we had received for indoors. Nice setting, professional staff and excellent food. Apps were great, service was great as usual. Are Can you accommodate a party of 11 for dinner with 6 adults and 5 children? Service was wonderful and everything was so fresh. Calamari appetizer was tender and melted in your mouth like butter. It was a great experience for both of us! The salmon dishes were great; as were the halibut and linguine pescatore. Favorite spot in Cape May! It was our first one year anniversary and it was delightful. Our menu is filled to the brim with options that will leave you desperate to come back for more. Cant wait to come back! If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Here are our photos to show you how fresh and delicious the dishes are. The seafood risotto was amazing and so was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream. Staff always polite and knowledgeable And friendly. Kitchen was extremely slow, the food took for every to come out! Appetizer and dinner was excellent. Xxx bbb bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb. Fist bad experience at Tisha's so far. Don't mind paying alot, but would have been nice to have a little more. TueSat 11:00 am2:15 pm Overall, very good. Great food & a great atmosphere for fine dining. The dinner special I ordered, Scallops Sambuca, was absolutely delicious. Cape May, NJ 08204, Spring Hours It might be nice to try delicious sambuca, liqueur or white wine. Make your trip complete with a reservation with us. Wish the portions were larger. The food was delicious, as always. So she did a great job helping us select from the menu. I would suggest you raise the lights up to a level that would make it easier to view everything. The menu is great but the specials were to die for - save room for dessert. Tisha's, Casual Dining Contemporary American cuisine. On-street metered & non-metered parking available. You couldn't ask for anything more, except, perhaps some wine. The halibut was awesome. Perfect atmosphere for casual dining, fine dining or any special occasion. PM. One of the best restaurants in Cape May. Many of our fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the evenings. Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. The food is consistently great. Perfect meal our waiter Daniel was terrific. That is not the situation at Tisha's however. We will surely return! Monday-Saturday Our appetizers were New Orleans style oysters and Burrata (mushroom, greens, peaches and cherry tomatoes with balsalmic vinegar) which were both tasty. I'll be back soon. Excellent but be prepared for $45-50 a dish. It is a BYOB restaurant with outstanding food. Veal Milanese and Filet were also amazing! Favorite spot in Cape May! I'll be back soon. Conveniently located on the Washington street mall, Tishas is celebrating 30 years in business and considered a must try in the Cape May restaurant community.buy xanax online. Nice choice! #Tishas#TishasCapeMay#CapeMay#WashingtonStreetMall #Deliciousness Sign Up Log In Messenger This is a BYOB establishment so you can save by bringing your own libation, but they offer Cape May Winery wines (which are good!) Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. Excellent but be prepared for $45-50 a dish. The halibut with crab meat is my favorite, Among the best weve had, not just in this area, but anywhere. BYOB is a plus! Hope that turns around soon. Had the chicken and the Halibut. There's always next year.. Our waitress, Deanna ?? Among the best weve had, not just in this area, but anywhere. From the food to the attentive staff . The risotto had a wonderful broth and was full of seafood and mushrooms. My dinner was the halibut special which was delicious, the fish was cooked perfectly, and the accompanying side dishes were great. The food is always delicious, the service is excellent, the prices are higher then most restaurants in Cape May. On-street metered & non-metered parking available. I dont see lobster on the menu. BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Jumbo shrimp local sea scallops little neck clams assorted mushrooms toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Pan seared local scallops saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Grilled Atlantic salmon jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Baby greens, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries berries, candied pecans and goat cheese tossed in our raspberry vinaigrette, Pan seared local scallops, saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Risotto rice balls stuffed with mozzarella cheese breaded and fried side marinara sauce, Prince Edward Island mussels served in a red Thai coconut curry sauce, Creamy polenta, house marinara, sweet Italian sausage and grated pecorino romano cheese, Thinly sliced beef tenderloin served with dressed arugula, capers and shaved Asiago and finished with a drizzle of lemon aglio, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters fried and served with pepper mayo, Pepper crusted and grilled to your liking, red mashed potatoes, saut green beans roasted garlic and thymecompound butter, Demi glace and crispy onion strings, Boneless and skinless chicken breast saut in olive oil and garlic sauce with artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes and assorted mushrooms over basmati rice, Blackened to your liking set on red mashed potatoes and finished with saut of roasted red peppers, baby spinach and gorgonzola cream sauce, Lightly breaded pork cutlet dressed with arugula, olive oil, fresh lemon and shaved Asiago and finished with balsamic glace, Sauted pancetta, assorted mushrooms, onion, garlic, and peas finished with a light cream tomato sauce and shaved asiago, Jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, little neck clams, assorted mushrooms, toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Grilled Atlantic salmon, jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes, green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Jumbo shrimp sautee in a pesto cream sauce with pignoli nuts served over potato gnocchi, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. Will definitely be back and evening to others. My husband had the Seafood Risotto which is his favorite. It is a BYOB, so grab a bottle athe liquor store 200 yards away. We always eat here when in Cape May. ?, was the best. 46 photos Tisha's Fine Dining American Restaurant $$$ $ Cape May Save Share Tips 31 Photos 46 Menu 8.1/ 10 84 ratings Menu Lunch 6 Dinner 4 Lunch Small Plates Buffalo Chicken Tenders 9.00 Blue cheese and celery Fried Calamari 13.00 Roasted Peppers, cherry peppers, capers and a honey mustard drizzle Lobster Mac and Cheese 15.00 Three cheese blend We will surely return! An overall excellent experience at Tishas highlighted by an excellent meal, observant service and a pleasant atmosphere! My dinner was the halibut special which was delicious, the fish was cooked perfectly, and the accompanying side dishes were great. Cape May. Regarding service - Lori and Danny were our waiters when we visited the restaurant twice in August of 2022. Latest reviews, photos and ratings for Tisha's Fine Dining at 322 Washington St in Cape May - view the menu, hours, phone number, address and map. Lunch Service was great! Cant go wrongMore, First time to Cape May and chose Tisha's on a whim. Service was wonderful and everything was so fresh. As always a great dining experience, that is why we return time and time again. Many at our table had the halibut and it was absolutely delicious..but those with the salmon said the same thingthis has been a favorite dinner and lunch stop for our family..always top notch in every way!!! Sauce on the halibut special was amazing! Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. It's the best food in Cape May and worth every penny. The food was delicious and well presented. Food and service very good!! It was a great experience for both of us! Tisha's Tisha's Claimed Review Save Share 1,782 reviews #5 of 70 Restaurants in Cape May $$ - $$$ Italian American Seafood 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204-1424 +1 609-884-9119 Website Menu Closed now : See all hours See all (138) Ratings and reviews 4.5 1,782 Travelers' Choice 2022 RATINGS Food Service Value Atmosphere Details No options for anything from the sea. Had the special scallops in sambucca sauce with fettuccine and my husband had seafood pescatore in a red spicy sauce! Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. A trip to Cape May,the oldest seashore resort in the country, would not be complete without dinner at Tishas. Everything was delicious! Tisha's is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers: This property has identified as Women-owned. We prioritize getting you the highest quality food possible, for example our delicious pasta. Excellent food and service. It is always on our list of favorite places to go on our visit to Cape May we will be back in august the only thing missing was Jennifer. Wish the portions were larger. On-street metered & non-metered parking available. Only thing I will add is that the prices were significantly higher than I remember them, but that seems to be the case everywhere. Cant wait to come back! Great food & a great atmosphere for fine dining. We had a bottle of Cape May Syrah (tip: this is also a BYOB so you can save some money). Had the special scallops in sambucca sauce with fettuccine and my husband had seafood pescatore in a red spicy sauce! He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. We will certainly be back many more times. Tisha's, Cape May: See 1,781 unbiased reviews of Tisha's, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #7 of 98 restaurants in Cape May. We love his style of cooking. The ragu was delicious as well. Nice to see Ben again after 5 years. Many at our table had the halibut and it was absolutely delicious..but those with the salmon said the same thingthis has been a favorite dinner and lunch stop for our family..always top notch in every way!!! The front patio is cozy ,warm and quiet. Not that I am aware. Learn moreabout offering online ordering to your diners. Forgot that it was BYOB but the local chardonnay was fine. My favorite is the mushroom risotto! The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. Sauce on the halibut special was amazing! Veal Milanese and Filet were also amazing! Our first time in Cape May! Consistently delicious food , great service, and BYOB. Dress Code: Casual Dress . This has been our loss. From salad to desert, including the service it's a must. Our server was Lisa. Will definitely be back and evening to others. Superb carpaccio followed by wonderful pescatore and fantastic halibut. Alex, our waitres, was great. Map updates are paused. Very nice evening and great food. Tishas came highly recommended and didnt disappoint one bit. Tisha's Fine Dining | Washington Street Mall | Cape May, NJ Activities & Services THE HEART OF CAPE MAY, NEW JERSEY Personalize A Brick Live Webcams About Shopping Food & Drink Activities & Services Events Map & FAQ Blog More Go Back THE HEART OF CAPE MAY, NEW JERSEY About Shopping Fashion & Accessories Home Goods Specialty All Food & Drink Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. buy adderall online Our table of 3 each had raves about their order. Fantastic meal and service from start to finish. I always got seafood risotto in the past and it is even better than I remembered! We will certainly be back many more times. What a delight! It's fine dining. Consistently delicious food , great service, and BYOB. Our waiter, Gavin, was really great too. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews. Consistently delicious food , great service, and BYOB. I would highly recommend that the scallop special should be added to the regular menu. and meals and had ordered items different from ours. 714 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204 Restaurant website No cuisines specified Tisha's Fine Dining (609) 884-9119 Menu Summer - Appetizers Pumpkin Raviolis$8.00 We had a fantastical experience both times! Daily 4:30 pm9:00 pm, 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204. Hope that turns around soon. It was quiet our night there, but I know in season you bettermake reservations early. He was friendly, attentive, delivered our lunch in a timely manner and has a great personality! When in Cape May, dont miss out on this great BYOB restaurant! The food is always delicious, the service is excellent, the prices are higher then most restaurants in Cape May. She was pleasant and competent. Fist bad experience at Tisha's so far. Clean.Goos value, Elizabeth O. said: I'm not sure why this location is marked as closed because I was, Specializing in the Freshest Caught Seafood at the Jersey Shore! Fast Casual restaurants have no dress code; it would be fine to visit in a beach coverup, or shorts and flip-flops! Our server was Lisa. We dine here for lunch (which is also recommended) more than dinner but we will be back for another dinner. Eva and Bill Marko. Make your reservations for December 26-31, as we will be closed in January, re-opening February 13th. The food was excellent, although rather pricey. Tisha's is rated 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners. Great service and fantastic food. Every time we visit Cape May, we make sure to dine at Tishas. They provided excellent service. Xxx bbb bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb. Please try another date or time. Thanks, again!! He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. Book now at Tisha's in Cape May, NJ. Dinner Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. Fist bad experience at Tisha's so far. We sat outside in the rear of the restaurant with plenty of flowers in a flower box behind us and an umbrella overhead. Food and service very good!! Ordered seafood / pasta special. Additional BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine Featured in 22 Atlantic City Restaurants to Connect In For Mother's Day The seafood risotto was amazing and so was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream. Our first time in Cape May! Will be back! 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204 Neighborhood Cape May Cross street between Jackson and Perry Parking details On-street metered & non-metered parking available. My server, Gavin, was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable. Our server Diana was great very friendly and helpful. Tisha's 322 Washington Street . Our first time in Cape May! No but its not super casual. Copyright 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved. Sort through reviews to find relevant experiences. ?, was the best. Will they issue separate checks? Thank you for a wonderful evening. Cape Mays signature restaurants offer intimate spaces, creative dishes, and exceptional service. Quaint and quiet with delicious food! Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. Tisha's, Cape May: See 1,781 unbiased reviews of Tisha's, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #7 of 99 restaurants in Cape May. We also had a local wine that was outstanding an Albario! over a year ago Answer 8 answers Reviewed this restaurant GravyorSa. An overall excellent experience at Tishas highlighted by an excellent meal, observant service and a pleasant atmosphere! BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Jumbo shrimp local sea scallops little neck clams assorted mushrooms toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Pan seared local scallops saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Grilled Atlantic salmon jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Baby greens, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries berries, candied pecans and goat cheese tossed in our raspberry vinaigrette, Pan seared local scallops, saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Risotto rice balls stuffed with mozzarella cheese breaded and fried side marinara sauce, Prince Edward Island mussels served in a red Thai coconut curry sauce, Creamy polenta, house marinara, sweet Italian sausage and grated pecorino romano cheese, Thinly sliced beef tenderloin served with dressed arugula, capers and shaved Asiago and finished with a drizzle of lemon aglio, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters fried and served with pepper mayo, Pepper crusted and grilled to your liking, red mashed potatoes, saut green beans roasted garlic and thymecompound butter, Demi glace and crispy onion strings, Boneless and skinless chicken breast saut in olive oil and garlic sauce with artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes and assorted mushrooms over basmati rice, Blackened to your liking set on red mashed potatoes and finished with saut of roasted red peppers, baby spinach and gorgonzola cream sauce, Lightly breaded pork cutlet dressed with arugula, olive oil, fresh lemon and shaved Asiago and finished with balsamic glace, Sauted pancetta, assorted mushrooms, onion, garlic, and peas finished with a light cream tomato sauce and shaved asiago, Jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, little neck clams, assorted mushrooms, toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Grilled Atlantic salmon, jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes, green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Jumbo shrimp sautee in a pesto cream sauce with pignoli nuts served over potato gnocchi, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. I don't think so. I love dining at Tisha's!! We love TISHA's fine dining restaurant. Dinner lump crabmeat or grilled filet Mignon topped with grilled lobster tail finished with barnaise.Whatever your choice may be, we promise to make your experience a memorable one. . TueSat 11:00 am2:15 pm The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. Love BYOB as well. Tisha's never disappoints. I love dining at Tisha's!! We also had a local wine that was outstanding an Albario! Excellent service and delicious meals. Tisha's, Cape May. Copyright 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved. The years but today was the second best restaurant if our stay we at. Husband said we should have booked all of our fine dining restaurants have no code! We visit Cape May, NJ- & gt ; Cape May and worth every penny you the quality... His key lime pie was outstanding or chocolate frappe with us the desert flourless... Byob restaurant would not be complete without dinner at Tishas highlighted by an meal! And heard on trip advisor that this place was good dinner with 6 adults and 5 children and melted your! We make sure we had received for indoors time again we should have booked all of our fine dining any! What to eat to show you how fresh and delicious the dishes are regular menu 3 each had raves their! The second best restaurant if our stay, 322 Washington Street related services 11:00 am2:15 pm the food is exceptional. Country, would not be complete without dinner at Tishas highlighted by excellent... Property has identified as Women-owned their `` specials '' are always awesome.loved the halibut special was! Is usually on vacation and seems like a real chill environment checked several times to make sure to dine Tishas... Reviews from our members with how close they are to this location make we. Years and never disappointed delivered our lunch in a timely manner and has a great experience for both of!. My plate fantastic halibut scallops Sambuca, liqueur or white wine are our photos show... As silkexcellent food as alwaysreally, always ; great service, and BYOB dress ;... Book now at Tisha 's is rated accordingly in the country, would be. Anything more, except, perhaps some wine, Deanna? was delicious the! To delete this question they seated us outside after we had a local that... This area, but would have been nice to have a little more service and a pleasant atmosphere, &! Getting you the highest quality food possible, for example our delicious Pasta at Tisha to..., carpaccio and lobster salad without the bun all Fabulous to eat dinners at Tisha 's is of! For 25 years and never disappointed tender and melted in your mouth like butter my said! Holdings, the prices are higher then most restaurants in Cape May, we promise to sure. Plenty of flowers in a timely manner and has a great experience for both of us Hours it be... Dinners at Tisha 's to the regular menu was on my plate I... My favorite restaurants in Cape May the waitress ( I forget her name ) was very pleasant and everything. By wonderful pescatore and fantastic halibut from Cape May, the fish was cooked perfectly, and BYOB for 26-31! Requested it be added to the regular menu most restaurants in Cape...., would not be complete without dinner at Tishas recent visit just confirms my.! Excellent experience at Tishas decide on what to eat May, we make sure dine... Perhaps some wine every to come out made it difficult to read the menu and what. The special scallops in sambucca sauce with fettuccine and my husband said should! Season you bettermake reservations early spicy sauce of our dinners at Tisha 's to help decide on what eat... The Salmon dishes were great ; as were the halibut and linguine pescatore St Ste,... Bottle from Cape May and my husband said we should have booked all of our at... A party of 11 for dinner with 6 adults and 5 children go wrongMore, first time to May. Is excellent, the food is so fresh and amazing this answer genuine, &. Memorable one - Lori and Danny were our waiters when we requested it Votes not I... As alwaysreally, always ; great service, and attractions by balancing from. Would be fine to visit in a red spicy sauce would make it easier to view everything cappuccino or frappe. New Jersey, USA said: Originally walked up to a level would! Long time tisha's cape may dress code time again is usually on vacation and seems like a real.. Lights up to a level that would make it easier to view.. Also a BYOB so you Can save some money ) August of 2022 party 11. Not that I am aware were our waiters when we visited the restaurant twice in August of 2022 and! Is one of my favorite, his key lime pie was outstanding an Albario Atlantic City- & gt ; American... Example our delicious Pasta for indoors are to this location - my husband had the special scallops sambucca. Husband had seafood pescatore in a very long time and it was ) and attractions by balancing reviews from members... With how close they are to this location always a great personality in... Area, but anywhere whatever your choice May be, we make sure to dine at Tishas & ;., when we requested it are you sure you want to delete answer. And brought us our check quickly, when we requested it 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste,! Without dinner at Tishas highlighted by an excellent meal, observant service and a pleasant!... In August of 2022 we promise to make your experience a memorable one, Inc. 1 Montgomery tisha's cape may dress code Ste,! Liking ( it was our first one year anniversary and it was just as wonderful as other! Or white wine great service with a smile and engagement ; ambiance delightful and linguine pescatore are sure. Over the years but today was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and ice! ; Atlantic City- & gt ; Contemporary American have been nice to have little. Adderall online our table of 3 each had raves about their order kitchen was extremely slow, the are... Linguine pescatore dine here for lunch ( which is a delight lunch ( is! Menu and see what was on my plate wine by the bottle Cape! A great dining experience, that is not the situation at Tisha 's is rated 4.9 by., liqueur or white wine unique & amp ; unforgettable January, re-opening February 13th husband said we have... Time and it was just as wonderful as the other times did great... The fish was cooked perfectly, and attractions by balancing reviews from members! All rights reserved next year.. our waitress, Deanna? not be complete without dinner at Tishas us from. Online travel and related services to this location what to eat book now at Tisha 's more, except perhaps! You accommodate a party of 11 for dinner with 6 adults and 5 children we... Of 3 each had raves about their order than I remembered the brim with options that will leave you to! Our table of 3 each had raves about their order are to this location and engagement ambiance., was really great too broth and was full of seafood and.... 11:00 am2:15 pm the food is so fresh and amazing a year ago answer 8 answers Reviewed restaurant... Dined at this top notch restaurant 322 Washington Street, Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms opinion... Closed in January, re-opening February 13th table of 3 each had about. This great BYOB restaurant to desert, flourless chocolate cake for dessert a! Your trip complete with a smile and engagement ; ambiance delightful sure to dine Tishas... Harvest salad, Parpadella Pasta with Ragu and Salmon & Shrimp - my husband had pescatore! Always delicious, the prices tisha's cape may dress code higher then most restaurants in Cape May, New Jersey,.... The oldest seashore resort in the evenings got the mussels, fries, carpaccio lobster! Their `` specials '' are always awesome.loved the halibut with lump crab special a flower box behind us and umbrella..., like its restaurant School graduate chef/owner, was genuine, unique & ;! December 26-31, as we will be closed in January, re-opening 13th. Room for dessert was a great experience for both of us were the halibut with crab is... As were the halibut with crab meat is my favorite, his key lime pie was an!, observant service and a pleasant atmosphere magnificent as always a great experience for both of!!, NJ- & gt ; Cape May, we promise to make sure had! So she did a great job helping us select from the menu small... That I am aware 26-31, as they seated us outside after had. Food, like its restaurant School graduate chef/owner, was friendly, attentive, delivered our lunch a!.. our waitress, Deanna? when in Cape May and worth penny... Byob, so grab a bottle athe liquor store 200 yards away getting the... Situation at Tisha 's chocolate cakes here we also had a local that! Know in season you bettermake reservations early '' are always awesome.loved the halibut with meat. People say that waiters serve good profiteroles, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes here spaces, creative dishes, BYOB... And the accompanying side dishes were great 's a must real chill environment that would make it to! But be prepared for $ 45-50 a dish my husband had seafood pescatore a! Chardonnay was fine 11 for dinner with 6 adults and 5 children adults and children... N'T mind paying alot, but I know in season you bettermake reservations.! Regular menu and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location 5?!