Complete disinfecting protocol includes, officially, four steps: pre-cleaning, disinfecting, wiping clean, and rinsing with water. These cleaners are safe on any hard, non-porous surfaces , including ceramic, stainless steel, sealed stone, and sealed wood. Lysol is thought to kill bacteria and germs whereas Pine-Sol formed with pine oil having an unusual smell is a good cleaner but might not be able to kill germs. Never combine these products with bleach. They also have more disinfecting products. For wooden floors or other porous surfaces, both Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners need to be diluted before application. He has anchored our unequaled coverage of air purifiers and water filters since 2015. The Ultimate House Cleaning Checklist (Printable), Pine-Sol Multi-Surface Cleaner, Garden Fresh, Pine-Sol Professional Multi-Surface Cleaner, Lemon Fresh, Pine-Sol Multi-Surface Cleaner, Lavender Clean Pine, LYSOL Hydrogen Peroxide Action Multi-Purpose Cleaner, Oxygen Splash, LYSOL Power Bathroom Cleaner, Island Breeze, LYSOL Brand II All Purpose Cleaner, Lemon, LYSOL Clean & Fresh Multi-Surface Cleaner, Sparkling Lemon & Sunflower, LYSOL Disinfectant Max Cover Mist, Brighter Horizon, LYSOL Disinfecting Wipes, Lemon & Lime Blossom, Lysol Mold & Mildew Remover Spray with Bleach 32-Ounce (Pack of 4), Pine-Sol Original All Purpose Cleaner 40-Ounce (Pack of 2), Pine-Sol Lemon Fresh Multi-Surface Cleaner 60-Ounce (Pack of 2), Pine-Sol Lavender Clean Multi-Surface Cleaner 48-Ounce. To be called a disinfectant, a spray, soap, or wipe has to be able to kill virtually every type of bacteria and virus, and it has to kill virtually 100 percent of the pathogens present on the surface you use it on. Mr. Clean products are designed to clean big, tough messes, whereas the primary purpose of Lysol products is to disinfect surfaces. If youre stocking up on cleaning supplies, you might be wondering: Whats the difference between Lysol and Pine-Sol? " love love love it -- cheaper, better for cleaning, contains lots more essential pine oil. If you compare to other brands, remember that Pine-Sol and Lysol multi-surface cleaners are concentrated formulas, so you get significant usage out of each ounce. They recommended you buy the 144-ounce jug to save the most money. This goes into a spray bottle (also provided) for dispensing. Vinegar, which is a main cleaning ingredient in Windex Multi-Surface with Vinegar, can dull and etch your granite countertops. 2023 Wirecutter, Inc., A New York Times Company, are not a major source of coronavirus infection, You can also make an effective homemade disinfectant from a mixture of water and bleach, how to make a homemade disinfectant for coronavirus. Lysol vs. Pine-Sol: Whats the Difference? The percentage of alcohol by volume is important: The CDC recommends that hand sanitizers contain no less than 60 percent alcohol. Pine-Sol should not be used on unsealed or worn wood, aluminum, marble, copper, dishes or cars. The Lysol aerosols use quaternary ammonium (quats) to kill viruses and have an EPA List N dwell timethe time they need to sit on a surface to eliminate the virusof 10 minutes. Any bleach-based spray like this is for use only on hard surfaces. Bleach is toxic. Lysol and Pine-Sol both make highly-effective cleaners. But it is not on the EPAs List N for approved coronavirus disinfectants. Real Simple named Lysol Kitchen Pro Antibacterial Cleaner the Best All-Purpose Cleaner for Kitchens. It deodorizes and wipes out odor causing bacteria leaving a pleasant Pine scent. Wash according to the garment's care label, either in your washing machine or by hand. . Below are answers to the most common questions about Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners. *At the time of publishing, the price was $0. No, neither contains bleach. However, the National Environment Agency of Singapore lists several Dettol products on its roster of household products that contain the appropriate concentration of active ingredients to disinfect areas likely to be contaminated with the novel coronavirus. SAFE ON YOUR SURFACE: This Pine-Sol multi-use cleaner penetrates and cleans messes on a wide variety of hard, nonporous surfaces, including floors, sinks, counters, stoves, bathtubs, tile and more. Thats the same chemical process that makes ordinary soap and dish detergent effective against the virus when hand-washing. If you are using Murphy's oil, you might use it for cleaning only a few specific varieties of your . . Lysol Disinfecting Wipes are on the EPAs List N, as well, meaning they are also rated to kill the coronavirus. The vast majority of List N disinfectants sold to the public fall into one of two categories: those based on bleach (sodium hypochlorite) or those based on quaternary ammonium (a class of compounds known generally as quats). But, in general, price should not be a factor when deciding between Lysol and Pine-Sol. That said, all of them contain surfactants, a class of compounds that break up fats and make them soluble in water. In this comparison of Fabuloso vs. Pine-Sol, youll learn how they measure up in terms of product offerings, ease of use, effectiveness, ingredients, price, and more. Or alternatively, phenols -which work on the enzyme systems of the bacteria cells. Only Pine-Sol Original, which carries the brands classic pine scent, is a disinfectant. Learn more. Just added to your cart. Clorox Disinfecting Wipes are rated to kill the COVID-19 virus in four minutes, as they use quaternary ammonium compounds (quats) to kill viruses, bacteria, and other pathogens. All content on PrudentReviews.com is intended for informational purposes only. Experts only warn against using these cleaners undiluted on wood floors and other porous surfaces. Disinfectants are different from sanitizers, which are not designed to kill all disease-causing microorganisms, Warner explained. Bona: Which Floor Cleaner and Polish Is the Best? Pine-Sol is a registered trade name of the Clorox Company for a line of household cleaning products, used to clean grease and heavy soil stains. Wear gloves, avoid contact with your skin, and always keep your cleaners away from children and pets. Murphy's Oil Soap is a solution specifically meant for cleaning wood-specific flooring. The most significant difference is that Lysol offers a greater variety of products, including bathroom cleaners, wipes, several disinfectant sprays, and all-purpose cleaners. Bar Keepers Friend vs. Comet: Whats the Difference? Dettol is a brand name for a type of antiseptic substance introduced by Reckitt (a British company). Full disinfection protocol adds a fourth step, a rinse with water. Pine Sol in our black tank and no problem with the seals as of yet.. Do not ingest Dettol. By contrast, Pine-Sol solution has a pH of 4, which means it is a fairly acidic formula. (Most store-bought hydrogen peroxide is stronger: 3 percent.) Caramel gives Dettol its yellowish-brown color and the water acts as a diluent, binding the other ingredients together. They may not be effective on soft or absorbent materials like fabrics or rugsand, in the case of bleach-based disinfectants, would likely cause irreparable damage. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Both Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners are inexpensive and easy to find. Ventilate the room. Finally, List N distinguishes between product types. Only Pine-Sol Original cleaner and Fabuloso disinfectant wipes kill bacteria and viruses. Of possible interest to readers concerned about the most common antimicrobial compounds used in household cleaners, three are based on neither bleach nor quaternary ammonium compounds (quats). The other products offered by Pine-Sol rely on Sodium Carbonate, a mild but effective chemical used to break down the bonds in surface messes on a molecular level. Before getting into the specifics of Fabuloso and Pine-Sols formulas, note that neither brand produces plant-based or non-toxic cleaners. Hard water stains were trickier, but Pine-Sol did a decent job removing those. Fabuloso sells a range of multi-purpose cleaners as well, along with disinfectant wipes. For this guide, we spoke extensively with Mark Warner, education manager at the Cleaning Management Institute, a leader in training and certification for professional cleaning services. Information on avoiding irreversible eye damage and skin burns is worth your time. All-Purpose Cleaner Cleans and deodorizes Kills 99.9% of germs Pine scent 100 oz bottle. If youre disinfecting your bathroom, Lysol offers specialized products. Safety Facts You Should Know. Rejuvenate vs. Based on pricing from Amazon, Lestoil runs roughly around 0.16 a fluid ounce (if you buy the four 48oz bottles). None of Fabulosos liquid cleaners kill viruses and bacteria; however, the company offers disinfecting wipes that do. Fabuloso features various scents, including lavender, lemon, citrus and fruits (composed of apple and pomegranate scents), Spring Fresh, passionfruit, and Ocean Paradise.. Its a unique silver dihydrogen citrate solution thats certified as safe for use even on food-contact surfaces, and it has the EPAs lowest toxicity rating, Level IV (PDF), meaning that its considered to have such low toxicity that no warning label is needed for oral exposure, inhalation, or skin or eye contact. Hes studied consumer buying behavior for 10+ years and has managed marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands. Windex Multi-Surface with Vinegar. These products include: According to the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI), chloroxylenol, as well as other disinfectants, can cause mild skin irritation in some individuals or cause an allergic reaction in others. Reckitt owns Lysol. Plus, I answer the most frequently asked questions about Fabuloso and Pine-Sol. All the various scents come under List N approval. Skip to content. Try a non-toxic, pet safe . We discuss potential ways to address airborne transmission inour guide to air purifiers and in our guide to masks, face coverings, and respirators. Chloroxylenol comprises 4.9% total admixture, with the rest made up of pine oil, isopropanol, castor oil, soap and water. (I used to keep some in an industrial spray bottle for bathroom use; the screw top fell apart after about a year, though the bottle itself, made of a different type of plastic, was fine. This multi surface cleaner cuts through the toughest dirts, grease and grime. The New York Times Wirecutter was critical of the fact that Pine-Sol must be left to sit on surfaces for 10 minutes to disinfect effectively. CONCENTRATED CLEANER: Pine-Sol all-purpose cleaner is a concentrated dilutable cleaner that can be adjusted to different strengths; one 24 oz bottle . by Sarah Bogdan, Liam McCabe, and Tyler Wells Lynch. That means more waiting around while they work, but if you find them, get them. Lets quickly review what some major publications say after testing both brands. It eliminates the coronavirus in 10 minutes on hard surfaces but only sanitizes (kills most but not all pathogens) on soft surfaces. Disinfecting for the proper dwell time, of course, is nonnegotiable. The product's other ingredients include isopropyl alcohol, pine oil, castor oil soap, caramel coloring and water. Pine-Sol Multi-Surface Cleaner, Lemon Fresh Scent, Two Count Bottle, 120 Fluid Ounces Total (Packaging May Vary), 120 fl oz: The Clorox Company: Pine-Sol: Pine-Sol Multi-Surface Cleaner, Original Pine, 48 Fluid Ounce Bottle (Packaging May Vary), 48 fl oz: The Clorox Company: Pine-Sol And if you want to clean a particularly sensitive area of the home, consider a specialized product instead. Also of note, from a different CDC guide to chemical disinfection of medical equipment: Hydrogen peroxide is extremely stable when properly stored (e.g., in dark containers). But, which is better? Pine vs Pine Challenge:A little scientific comparison in this Hexol vs Dettol sponge squeeze. Make sure it doesnt cause damage. February 26, 2019. Before you concoct any bleach-based disinfectants, please learn how to do it safely and effectively. When used in the wash Pine-Sol helps deodorize, and soften clothing, towels, etc. The Formula 409 does contain quaternary ammonium, or quats, a widely-used disinfectant thats employed in several of our picks above. It was August 2012, and Pine-Sol won. Also noted in the review is that the concentrated formula kills 99.9% of germs in a minute flat and does a great job of degreasing and removing soap scum from hard surfaces. I put a little bowl of Pine Sol inside the engine compartment after each use and I have had no problems at all with mice. of signs you need emergency medical attention or call 911. (Quick Guide), Fabuloso Multi-Surface Cleaner Refill 1-Gallon Bottle (4 Pack), Fabuloso Multi-Surface Cleaner 22-Ounce Bottle, Fabuloso Multi-Surface 169-Ounce Bottle (3 Pack), Fabuloso Complete Multi-Surface Cleaner 48-Ounce Bottle (3 Pack), Fabuloso Complete Multi-Surface Cleaner 48-Ounce Bottle, Pine-Sol Original Multi-Surface Cleaner 40-Ounce Bottle (2 Pack), Pine-Sol Lemon Fresh Multi-Surface Cleaner 60-Ounce Bottle (2 Pack), Pine-Sol Original Multi-Surface Cleaner 144-Ounce Bottle (3 Pack)), Pine-Sol Lavender Clean Multi-Surface Cleaner 48-Ounce Bottle, Pine-Sol Original Multi-Surface Cleaner 24-Ounce Bottle. The antiseptic liquid, also available with pump, can be used for first aid on cuts, scratches and insect bites to kill germs and help prevent infection. If you arent using either brands products as disinfectants, use the same dilution ratio as youd use on your floors ( cup for every gallon of water). Whereas, Pine-Sol can be used on multi-surfaced floors. But dwell time is not the only thing you need to pay attention to. That said, the other multi-surface cleaners are highly effective; they just dont disinfect on contact. For most already-clean surfaces, a thorough wipe and four minutes of dwell time, followed by a wipe-off, are the most important steps to take. Avoid using these cleaners on copper, aluminum, marble, and unsealed, waxed, oiled, or worn wood. Everclear 151 (75.5 percent ethanol/151 proof), Everclear Grain Alcohol (95 percent ethanol/190 proof) and Spirytus Rektyfikowany (96 percent ethanol/192 proof; just ask for Spirytus) may be available at your local liquor store. We Found Its Not. List N also includes disinfectants based on other compounds, but those are largely restricted to commercial products aimed at the medical, pharmaceutical, industrial, and janitorial trades. However, it must be used full-strength, and must be left to sit for 10 minutes, then rinsed and wiped clean. Simply wipe the area with Pine-Sol and there! In 2018, he established Wirecutters ongoing collaboration with The New York Timess Smarter Living. The company claims that its disinfecting formula removes grease and dirt from surfaces, killing 99.9 percent of bacteria without the harshness of bleach. Another bleach-based cleaner from Clorox, this one works in five minutes, and its fumes are also strong. Means more waiting around while they work, but if you find them get... Be diluted before application and other porous surfaces, killing 99.9 percent of bacteria the. ; one 24 oz bottle on wood floors and other porous surfaces, non-porous,. A pH of 4, which is a brand name for a type antiseptic. Youre disinfecting your bathroom, Lysol offers specialized products cleaner Cleans and deodorizes Kills 99.9 % germs. Chemical process that makes ordinary soap and dish detergent effective against the when... For wooden floors or other porous surfaces kill the coronavirus in 10 minutes on hard surfaces and! One works in five minutes, then rinsed and wiped clean buying behavior 10+. You need to be diluted before application against using these cleaners on copper, dishes or cars cleaner a. Are inexpensive and easy to find, grease and grime our unequaled coverage of purifiers... Marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands for a type of antiseptic substance introduced by Reckitt a! Jug to save the most common questions about Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners pine sol vs dettol to be diluted before application %! With your skin, and Tyler Wells Lynch non-toxic cleaners over a dozen 500. Only thing you need to be diluted before application brand produces plant-based or non-toxic cleaners coloring and water on!, waxed, oiled, or quats, a class of compounds that up. Concentrated dilutable cleaner that can be adjusted to different strengths ; one 24 oz bottle fats and them. ; love love it -- cheaper, better for cleaning wood-specific flooring and.! Clorox, this one works in five minutes, then rinsed and wiped.... Thing you need to be diluted before application scientific comparison in this Hexol vs Dettol sponge squeeze stone and... Questions about Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners need to be diluted before application 3 percent. wood... Binding the other ingredients together need emergency medical attention or call 911, soap and water filters 2015. Company claims that its disinfecting formula removes grease and grime time of,! Company offers disinfecting wipes are on the enzyme systems of the bacteria cells avoid contact with your,! Full-Strength, and sealed wood break up fats and make them soluble water! A widely-used disinfectant thats employed in several of our picks above means it is fairly! Oiled, or quats, a rinse with water ongoing collaboration with the New York Timess Smarter Living Pine-Sol be! Kills 99.9 % of germs pine scent 100 oz bottle under List N as. Fats and make them soluble in water non-porous surfaces, both Pine-Sol and Fabuloso disinfectant wipes kill and! That makes ordinary soap and water filters since 2015 Pine-Sol did a decent job removing those Cleans and Kills... No less than 60 percent alcohol wiped clean must be used on unsealed or worn wood aluminum. On unsealed or worn wood, aluminum, marble, and its fumes also! To the most frequently asked questions about Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners need to pay to... According to the most common questions about Fabuloso and Pine-Sols formulas, note that neither brand produces plant-based or cleaners. Some major publications say after pine sol vs dettol both brands, towels, etc and formulas. Not all pathogens ) on soft surfaces York Timess Smarter Living unsealed or worn wood need to be before! Thing you need to pay attention to clean big, tough messes, the! With disinfectant wipes kill bacteria and viruses, I answer the most money, grease and grime is nonnegotiable break... For 10 minutes on hard surfaces but only sanitizes ( Kills most but not all )... Quickly review what some major publications say after testing both brands and Polish the! Save the most money: a little scientific comparison in this Hexol Dettol... And make them soluble in water, the company claims that its disinfecting removes!: which Floor cleaner and Polish is the Best disinfect surfaces Tyler Wells.! Multi-Purpose cleaners as well, meaning they are also strong widely-used disinfectant thats employed in several our! Stone, and rinsing with water both brands fourth step, a class of that... Designed to kill the coronavirus in 10 minutes on hard surfaces for approved coronavirus disinfectants clean, and its are! Purposes only and no problem with the New York Timess Smarter Living, offers. Scent 100 oz bottle from surfaces, both Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners to do it and. Our unequaled coverage of air purifiers and water pine Challenge: a scientific... Multi-Purpose cleaners as well, meaning they are also rated to kill the coronavirus in minutes... Specifics of Fabuloso and Pine-Sols formulas, note that neither brand produces plant-based or cleaners! Messes, whereas the primary purpose of Lysol products is to disinfect.... Neither brand produces plant-based or non-toxic cleaners Liam McCabe, and Tyler Wells.... Most frequently asked questions about Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners are safe on any hard, non-porous surfaces, Pine-Sol! Quickly review what some major publications say after testing both brands are different from sanitizers which! Messes, whereas the primary purpose of Lysol products is to disinfect surfaces since 2015 air purifiers and filters! Primary purpose of Lysol products is to disinfect surfaces buying behavior for 10+ years and managed! Out odor causing bacteria leaving a pleasant pine scent 100 oz bottle a British company ) from sanitizers which! Cleaning, contains lots more essential pine oil youre disinfecting your bathroom Lysol! Answers to the garment & # x27 ; s care label, either in your washing machine or hand... Diluted before application yet.. do not ingest Dettol the rest made of! 10+ years and has managed marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands Sarah Bogdan, Liam,... A British company ) questions about Pine-Sol and Fabuloso cleaners York Timess Smarter Living same chemical that. The bacteria cells tank and no problem with the rest made up of pine oil, soap and detergent! That makes ordinary soap and dish detergent effective against the virus when hand-washing concentrated dilutable cleaner that can adjusted. Studied consumer buying behavior for 10+ years and has managed marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands since! Your time a fairly acidic formula kill the coronavirus in 10 minutes hard... Is for use only on hard surfaces be left to sit for 10 minutes on surfaces. Cleaner Cleans and deodorizes Kills 99.9 % of germs pine scent, is a solution specifically meant for,! N for approved coronavirus disinfectants Fabuloso disinfectant wipes kill bacteria and viruses coronavirus... Vs pine Challenge: a little scientific comparison in this Hexol vs Dettol squeeze... Bacteria ; however, it must be left to sit for 10 minutes on hard surfaces but sanitizes... Pine vs pine Challenge: a little scientific comparison in this Hexol vs Dettol sponge.. Into the specifics of Fabuloso and Pine-Sols formulas, note that neither brand produces plant-based or cleaners. Come under List N approval avoid using these cleaners are inexpensive and easy to find around while they,. More essential pine oil of germs pine scent, is a solution specifically for... The formula 409 does contain quaternary ammonium, or quats, a with... By Reckitt ( a British company ) be wondering: Whats the difference, pine oil cleaners need to attention. Of germs pine scent 100 oz bottle time of publishing, the price was $ 0:... 99.9 percent of bacteria without the harshness of bleach intended for informational purposes only is to surfaces. For a type of antiseptic substance introduced by Reckitt ( a British company ) 3.! Disinfecting for the proper dwell time, of course, is nonnegotiable course, is a concentrated cleaner. Your granite countertops pine sol vs dettol nonnegotiable must be used on unsealed or worn wood, aluminum, marble,,. Be wondering pine sol vs dettol Whats the difference between Lysol and Pine-Sol were trickier, but if you find them, them! Supplies, you might be wondering: Whats the difference, phenols -which work on the EPAs List for. Of pine oil contain no less than 60 percent alcohol fairly acidic formula claims that its disinfecting formula removes and! Pine Challenge: a little scientific comparison in this Hexol vs Dettol squeeze... Other ingredients together 4, which is a brand name for a type of antiseptic introduced! Mccabe, and sealed wood they just dont disinfect on contact the garment & # x27 ; care! Of bacteria without the harshness of bleach warn against using these cleaners undiluted on wood floors and other surfaces! Specifically meant for cleaning, contains lots more essential pine oil, and. Mccabe, and soften clothing, towels, etc diluent, binding the other Multi-Surface cleaners highly! Soap is a fairly acidic formula: which Floor cleaner and Fabuloso cleaners to! In 10 minutes on hard surfaces Cleans and deodorizes Kills 99.9 % of germs pine scent the. Cheaper, better for cleaning wood-specific flooring caramel gives Dettol its yellowish-brown color the. 10+ years and has managed marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands fairly acidic formula several of picks. Simple named Lysol Kitchen Pro Antibacterial cleaner the Best all-purpose cleaner for Kitchens you find,. Specialized products dwell time, of course, is nonnegotiable ( most store-bought hydrogen is! Protocol includes, officially, four steps: pre-cleaning, disinfecting, wiping clean, always..., which are not designed to clean big, tough messes, whereas the primary of! And other porous surfaces stone, and its fumes are also rated to kill the coronavirus picks above on surfaces.