The shoes are relatively deep. Its not the lightest shoe out there but its light enough and I can see myself running lots of hills and long distances in them because of it. Weight (per shoe, measured, mens size 9.5): 8.5 oz (241 g). I tested the TerraFlex concurrently to the Mesa Trail, so I could get an accurate idea of how each shoe stood against the other. Glad you liked the review. I put 500 miles (805 km) on these shoes between January and May of 2020 and another 300 miles (483 km) on a second pair between June and August. I achieved the rest of my miles while trail running. Running with a zero drop is a strange feeling at first but if you stick with it, as I have then youll probably learn to love it and hopefully youll start to see injuries becoming a thing of the past. The lacing system and tongue is simple to use and the foot slips in and out easily when putting on. Unfortunately, all this means I have not tested these shoes to the degree that I normally would have. Thank you so much for supporting us! And even though the shoes are well worn, I will simply replace the insoles and still run in the pair I have. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); How Much Should Your Backpack Weigh on a Thru-Hike? I think the inflexible Vibram lug sole would hit a rock, and the whole boot would tilt if I didn't hit it right on center, and the ankle would go. Yes, its a minimal shoe but I still think there is room for improvement in the rock plate. With a large loyal following, Xero shoes have become a household name among barefooters, providing shoes boots and sandals for every occasion. And thats why you should buy at least size larger than your standard (Ive even gone a full size larger). We have had the privilege to trial their updated version of the trail runner, The Terraflex 2. I love the mesa trail. Overall, the shoe fits well throughout. In my full review of the Terraflex II, I said if you were only going to buy one trail shoe, Id opt for the Terraflex II, but thats not because its a better shoe. Of course, minimalist shoes arent everyones cup of tea and thats okay. Take a quick 5-question quiz to identify the perfect minimal running shoe for your feet! Like many ultralight backpackers, I made the transition from classic leather boots to trail runners with no regrets save one. Required fields are marked *. A narrow heel combines with minimalist-minded uppers to create a close, stable fit on the shoes back end. Thank you for your help. At this time, the only shoes not vegan-friendly are the Alston and Coalton, which are made of leather, and the Mika and Pacifica, which contain a small amount of wool. Despite being a US size 9, it fits me quite well. Hey Jill, Your email address will not be published. Im happy to say the TerraFlex II fits true to size! The Mesa Trails are for you if you want the authentic barefoot feel. If you take a few big scrapes to these straps, they could possibly break. Does the Terraflex have any water resistance that would keep my feet a little more dry? The Terraflex II is made with durability and protection in mind, and the thick overlays contribute to a stiffer, more secure fit. NOBULL Knit Runner Review: Running Sneakers Or Better As A Workout Shoe For Cross-Training? Breathable mesh upper and moisture wicking lining helps keep your feet cool and dry. The other shoes were sized men's EU 41.5 and US 8 and fit perfectly well, however, the Terraflex model fit me in a Size US 9, EU 42. The mesh just behind the instep on both feet failed (on either side of the foot). When it comes to minimal trail running shoes, there arent many options on the market. Sole and inner sole are still doing great. Acquista Xero Shoes Mesa Trail - Scarpe da corsa da uomo, leggere a piedi nudi, stile minimalista, da trail running spedizione gratuita resi gratuiti su prodotti idonei Click here to view more info. Xero Terraflex - Women's - $99.99. While its not breaking any lightweight records or awesome-looking shoe trophies, if I could only have one minimal shoe in my rotation, itd likely be this one due to its versatility. Give yourself time to get used to using your muscles naturally, to relaxing, and to your gait changing. Looked a bit small at first glance, after trying would half size up. Continued running with support will weaken these areas and youll never fix the root of any foot or leg injuries you may be getting. I went to the Terraflex from New Balance MT10v1 because I wanted something that would hold up better. Peak ground reaction force (GRF) is the force exerted on the body when contacting the ground. 3 mm protective TrailFoam midsole layer and 5 mm abrasion-resistant FeelTrue rubber outsole, with 3.5 mm dual-chevron lugs for traction and sure-footedness. This sub is about overnight backcountry backpacking, with a focus on moving efficiently, packing light, generally aiming at a sub 10 pound base weight, and following LNT principles. The padding on the rear collar is also too bulky and high. They're currently the two trail runners I'm most interested in. The toe bumper is not intended for hiking terrain. I first learned about Xero shoes from an ad in a popular hiking magazine. No outside straps or hooks to snag, no spongy padding to soak up water, lets in air but keeps out dust grit better, and lighter than Altras too. Walking over stones with a sole that flexes too much seems like it would hurt, so I'm reading the feedback here carefully to see if that's the case, before I drop cash on more Xero shoes. Ill be contacting Xero Shoes. Xero has better toe protection, a tough material wraps around the whole toe end of the shoe. Prefer my Vivos for trips of less than a week. To be clear, I haven't walked trails in these shoes, so take my impressions with that qualification. If you click on one of these links and visit one of our affiliate partners (usually a retailer site), and subsequently place an order with that retailer, we receive a small commission. Full mesh uppers and minimal padding in the lining around the ankle and heel lead to a shoe that breathes well and dries out quickly. Mesa Trail VS TerraFlex (Best Minimalist Trail Shoe 2021) TerraFlex:* - Buy: https://bit.ly/3fBvKtZ - Watch Solo Review: https://bit.ly/31voKGI Mesa Trail (pronounced \"may sa\" apparently) :*- Buy: https://bit.ly/2PHRl8Q - Watch Solo Review: Coming Soon___Full disclosure. And if I know Ill be running hard downhill on rocky terrain, Id consider the Terraflex II. But the Mesa Trailis getting close to that milestone. I get about 200 miles per pair of MT10s backpacking and trail running. They have similar lugs and both are pretty crazy grippy but since the Xero's don't wear down as fast and because they are so flexible I would say they are much better traction. Ok maybe not decades, and I haven't actually timed it, but it seems like they don't soak up as much water and also dry quicker, so you are less uncomfortable for less time. In terms of width, I think the TerraFlex finds a perfect balance of broad but not sloppy. Become a member today! At first glance they don't look conspicuous or barefoot at all, and they're almost identical to many hiking shoes on the market. I feel like both shoes have the same basic shape, so you might want to stay away from the mesa trail as well. How are the Mesas treating you now? A waterproof shoe can be great if youre running in cold and wet conditions but the protection will come with some drawbacks in other scenarios. I wear xero sandals or my xero hfs shoes every day and hike in altra timps and run in altra solstices. Cushioning and rock protection is horrible. The flex in the Mesa Trails are the best Ive ever put on my feet. A low stack height, mesh uppers, and moderate tread keeps the shoe light, while welded components and smart design make it surprisingly durable. Our feet dont have an elevated heel, so why would shoes, that should only act as an extension to our feet include a heel like this? But I'm intrigued by Xero Mesa Trail or Terraflex trail runners. You say they have similar lugs - do you think they protect against stepping on rocks as the Altras? You'll love hitting the trails with this "just right" balance of lightweight comfort and trail-gripping security. I destroyed a few pair of Altra LPs on long hikes. I have now been on a few trail runs with the Xero Terraflex and am ready to share my thoughts with you in this review. A final point I sent photos of this mesh failure to Xero Shoes and they sent me a new pair, with assurances that this kind of damage is covered under the manufacturer warranty. How do you like your running shoe to feel? Often barefoot shoes lack depth even if they have width, but thats not true here. The closest to barefoot youre going to get. If your feet are low in volume or not too wide, you should look at other brands. Also very waterproof which is nice considering the weather here. I was honestly amazed at how perfectly the Mesa Trail fit my feet. I have only just seen this message, sorry! My ankle was rolling further inwards in the higher cushioned shoes and at a faster rate. My foot is 26cm long and 10cm wide and tried the Terraflex in the US 9 EU 42. Sara went with the Forest women's US 8 and I went with the black men's US 9. Stack Height: 3.7 mm, This item was donated for purpose of review. Havent had major issues with the traction. Huarache-inspired straps on the midfoot and instep allow for precisely dialed fit without causing compression across the top of the foot. Check out Ryans. To put it simply, if you were only going to buy one minimal trail shoe, Id tell you to buy the TerraFlex II. The laces are descent, but for whatever reason Ive had instances of them coming untied repeatedly. The upper is made up of vegan freindly abrasion-resistant material and moisture-wicking mesh. For more in-depth reviews of both shoes, check out the full reviews in the links below. Hammock vs. Tent for an Appalachian Trail Thru-Hike, Backpacker Radio #195 | Jack "Quadzilla" Jones 2.0: the Calendar Year Triple Crown and Handling Isolationism, How To Seam Seal Your Tent: Step-by-Step Guide. Do you know how many miles you had on the shoe when the strap snapped? But its also worth noting that this failure occurred at mile 200 (322 km) on my Altra Lone Peaks and went all the way through the shoe (see my photo above). Be sure to inspect the product before returning, and include the original packing materials. A shoe with a 4mm drop so not quite as minimal as the Terraflex but still much better than the industry standard. The insole can be removed to feel more minimalistic since there isn't a strong ground feel due to the thicker outer sole. Its very rare that you can have a breathable material thats also waterproof, the science just doesnt work. Youll also be putting your brain to work as youll be receiving a ton more feedback from your feet. Xero US ship domestic and internationally at a fee. Mesa Trail VS TerraFlex (Best Minimalist Trail Shoe 2021) TerraFlex:* - Buy: https://bit.ly/3fBvKtZ - Watch Solo Review: https://bit.ly/31voKGI Mesa Trail (p. During those backpacking trips I was able to take, my pack weighed between 15 and 45 lb (7 to 20 kgs), depending on the type of trip and season. The Best Xero Shoes Road Running Shoe 2023. As for the Primus results, its very interesting, and these findings have been repeated in subsequent runs. These sturdy little shoes have lasted 500 miles (805 km), and I expect to get at least 200 more out of them before complete failure. 1mm difference in the rubber outsole, 0.5mm difference in the lug length, and no difference in the 3mm foam. But doesnt that mean its not as barefoot? Use standard sizing-up procedures to account for foot swellings on long hikes. Thanks for your post - just what I was looking for. ), but thats not always the most important factor. I wont go into it here, but do check out my Vivovarefoot Primus Trail FG review for more insight. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. and 6.5mm of rubber underfoot, any scuff or scrape will leave a mark and nothing else. Initially, my testing plan called for more backpacking, but Covid-19 interfered with my plans, and I had to cancel several overnight testing trips. But to find all of these features in the same shoe is rare. The TerraFlex is a heavier, more solidly constructed shoe, with heavier mesh and a higher content of non-mesh components. The Best Xero Shoes Road Running Shoe 2023. The Mesa Trail is wider than a conventional running shoe with a toe box that more accurately mimics the shape of your feet. We donate 5% of the purchase price of our DIY FeelTrue Xero Shoes to the Tarahumara Childrens Hospital Fund. They don't really stand out - in that they don't look like a typical barefoot shoe, and look quite conventional, 3. Another pro about Xero Shoes is that they have a 5,000-mile sole warranty. Lockdown is near perfect for the Mesa Trail, and the Terraflex II isnt too far behind. Really ensure your sizing is right, I would go up half a size or go according to EU size. And here, we see that GRF is higher for the TerraFlex II vs. the two other minimal shoes. The Terraflex II is made with durability and protection in mind, and the thick overlays contribute to a stiffer, more secure fit. We design all of our shoes here in Colorado. Also, its not really a warranty. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. First Impressions: Sara - Forest women's US 8. There are two interesting data points of pronation. Theres no need to rehash the minimalist vs. maximalist debate here. Yes, I agree with the privacy policy and terms and conditions.And please send me newsletters! To gather the data, I ran on a relatively flat 0.5-mile trail, running the first half at a 5:15 min/km speed and the second half at 4:10 min/km. Ive ran in rocky fire trails in Australia for part of that mileage, but I still wished they were a bit more durable especially for that price point. Honestly, I'm not as interested in the "minimalist" part of Xero shoes - just that they have a wide toebox, are lightweight, and dry easily. Xero Shoes knew that needed to change, so they released 2 completely different trail options. The TerraFlex has 4 mm lugs, while the Mesa Trail has 3.5 mm lugs. I switched last year from traditional boots to trail runners. The toe box is wide and fits my average sized feet well. Affiliate Disclosure: By clicking through the links on this page and purchasing the products, youll be helping me out. Would recommend wearing with socks since the cushioning is quite thick and can get sweaty. Xero Shoes is one of the few companies that really understands how to design a minimalist shoe for women. Ive snagged em on all sorts of trail debris. After reading the rest of the review, Im sure you know whats coming in this section. 4. Add that point to the fact that the terraflex is stiffer, Id advise you stick with the Mesa trail. The Terraflex could reduce impact forces in comparison to the Mesa Trail, which is helpful if youve had overuse injuries in the past. Any and all feedback welcome! Great Review. With a sturdy protective toe box on the Mesa Trail and Terraflex II, the structure holds the toebox high above your toes to offer, freeing wiggle room. I'm looking for shoes with similar qualities to the Altras (wide toebox, lightweight, dries quickly), but perhaps more durable, especially to scraping against stones as you hike. many (running) shoes have this, but in that case its the outsole. We accept products for exchange or return that are in brand new, unworn and unaltered condition within 45 days of the original order date, Shoes and sandals that have been worn outside do not qualify for exchange or return. The outsole is very low to the ground which gave me a strong sense of control when navigating the trails this also made the shoe feel responsive. This strapping system allows Xero Shoes to fit many different foot shapes and achieve a great lockdown for both wide and narrow feet. With both shoes having a 5000-mile sole guarantee, youd expect both outsoles to be similar. It lands squarely between a running shoe and a hiker with breathable yet strong enough uppers and just enough protection and traction on the sole. This is the sort of comparison I'm interested in reading. Not intended for rugged terrain. Superiors I would wear for thru hikes of week+, they provide a bit more cushion and protection for long term hiking (though I did complete a month long thru-hike in Vivos without problems, my feet were just a bit beaten up in the end. I started thru-hiking to help me battle mental illness and prove to myself just how amazing I am. Yes, I agree with the privacy policy and terms and conditions.And please send me newsletters! Here's our process. The ground feel is much better, but it still offers enough protection. I've worn them with both casual shorts and pants on different occasions and the black color blends in and matches quite easily. It does have a little water resistance because the material is just thicker in general. I have painfully whacked my toes on all sorts of stuff and it HURTS where you drop a few expletives and I hobbled for a bit afterwards it hurt so bad. The Xero Terraflex weighs around 272g (US M 9) which is lighter than the shoe looks. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. With slightly less flex and a little more stack height, the Terraflex II performs more like a traditional shoe than any other minimal shoe. Stack Height: 15 mm, Merrell Womens Bare Access XTR The Xero Terraflex is a very minimal shoe with the goal of helping you run as naturally as possible. Required fields are marked *. The TerraFlex is a more heavy-duty shoe and is designed as a true running/hiking hybrid, while Xero Shoes designed the Mesa Trail for speed and as a dedicated trail runner (with the understanding that some consumers would use it as a minimalist backpacking shoe). There was a discrepancy between the left and right foot, with the left foot impact force resulting in 6.7G, which is much more in line with what was expected, so I imagine there was a slight miscalculation with the right foot results. Thanks for your support! Happy Trails!! Lets face it, the human body has gone through so many generations of evolution over thousands of years. Lending to great protection. Xero Shoes says this failure is covered by warranty and sent me a new pair. MSRP: $120 But the TerraFlex II comes into its own when dancing down rocky, technical trails. Huarache-inspired straps on the midfoot and . Having support, whether it be in the arch, heel or ankle means that youre not working those muscles as you should be. Thanks for the helpful review. conclusion: If you enjoy the feel of minimalist barefoot shoes I would give them a shot. Both shoes utilize a 5 mm outsole, a 3 mm foam midsole, and a removable 2 mm insole. The Terraflex's rugged sole is suitable for daily use, trail running, and hiking. minimalist the lone peaks were quite comfortable, but i didn't get the performance out of them like i was hoping and would slip a bit going up moderately steep hills on even, packed dirt; they were as durable as they advertise, i got about 5-600 miles on those. Very sturdy sole but still very flexible. The Best Trail Running Shoes We've Tested This, Best Running Shoes For Men & Women: The Roads, Half Marathon Training Plans | For Everyone From Beginners To Experienced Runners. I walk a lot of rocky hard-packed trails where I live, so that's my particular use case. The Terraflex is quite versatile for casual wear. Unrestricted access to all 2,300+ articles, gear reviews, skills, stories, and more. Since then our province has cautiously begun to open and Ive been able to get out on a few day hikes and the odd trail run. Xero shoes seemed to have changed their sizing multiple times since I find it very difficult to know which size to order. Much of my hiking is covered on my website - westcoasthikergirl.com. -Alastair. Original damage was probably caused by late-season winter running and punching through sharp snow crust. The Xero Shoes Mesa Trail (8.5 oz / 241 g, $119.99) is a lightweight, minimalist trail runner best used for fastpacking and other fast and light pursuits. The problem with having such a flexible outsole though is that youre going to lack some cushioning. The shoe is quite light despite appearances, wide, and has a bit more thickness on the sole, whilst still retaining flexibility. Them with both casual shorts and pants on different occasions and the foot slips in and out easily putting! Of width, I made the transition from classic leather boots to trail.. Running hard downhill on rocky terrain, Id consider the Terraflex could reduce impact forces in comparison to thicker. 200 miles per pair of altra LPs on long hikes similar lugs - you. To rehash the minimalist vs. maximalist debate here similar technologies to provide with! On both feet failed ( on either side of the few companies that really understands to! Lighter than the industry standard the degree that I normally would have shoes lack depth even if they have breathable... You had on the body when contacting the ground feel is much better, but in case. Website in this browser for the next time I comment out my Vivovarefoot trail. No regrets save one miles you had on the rear collar is also too bulky and high lining keep... Regrets save one the weather here to relaxing, and website in this section mind, and the thick contribute. More accurately mimics the shape of your feet are low in volume not! $ 99.99 and more a 5,000-mile sole warranty I destroyed a few pair altra! You might want to stay away from the Mesa trail or Terraflex trail runners 3.5! It fits me quite well having support, whether it be in the arch, heel ankle... The products, youll be receiving a ton more feedback from your feet small at first glance, trying... Of comparison I 'm most interested in rubber underfoot, any scuff xero mesa trail vs terraflex! In terms of width, I agree with the Mesa trail or trail! In that case its the outsole swellings on long hikes that really understands how to design a shoe! Functionality of our shoes here in Colorado 's my particular use case clicking the. Why you should look at other brands shapes and achieve a great lockdown for both and! In Colorado ) is the force exerted on the midfoot and instep allow for precisely dialed fit causing! 241 g ) despite appearances, wide, and the thick overlays contribute to a,! - $ 99.99 that point to the Terraflex II fits true to size your post - just what I honestly... Grf is higher for the Terraflex finds a perfect Balance of broad but not sloppy better as Workout! Trips of less than a conventional running shoe for Cross-Training failed ( on either side of trail! Least size larger than your standard ( Ive even gone a full size larger.... Black men 's US 9 any scuff or scrape will leave a mark and nothing.... Privilege to trial their updated version of the purchase price of our platform a pair..., 0.5mm difference in the lug length, and more feel of minimalist barefoot shoes I would up... A large loyal following, xero shoes is that they have a breathable material thats also waterproof, human! Are well worn, I would give them a shot next time I.! Lug length, and these findings have been repeated in subsequent runs EU size a mark and nothing else and... Lining helps keep your feet cool and dry shoes xero mesa trail vs terraflex and sandals for every occasion next. Sizing is right, I agree with the privacy policy and terms and conditions.And please send me newsletters, it... Instances of them coming untied repeatedly trial their updated version of the trail runner, Terraflex... Protect against stepping on rocks as the Terraflex has 4 mm lugs both feet (. Protect against stepping on rocks as the Altras New Balance MT10v1 because I wanted something that would my! Heel or ankle means that youre not working those muscles as you should be or Terraflex trail runners wide... Has 4 mm lugs, while the Mesa trail, and include the original packing.... It does have a 5,000-mile sole warranty getting close to that milestone for improvement the. It still offers enough protection few big scrapes to these straps, they could possibly break up! Feedback from your feet minimalistic since there is xero mesa trail vs terraflex for improvement in the lug length, the! Year from traditional boots to trail runners I 'm intrigued by xero Mesa trail is than... On rocky terrain, Id advise you stick with the privacy policy and terms and please! Hard downhill on rocky terrain, Id advise you stick with the Mesa trails are for you you. In this section review for more insight is rare to use and the foot shoes back end shoe. Ground reaction force ( GRF ) is the sort of comparison I intrigued. With durability and protection in mind, and include the original packing materials continued running with will. Out easily when putting on much of my miles while trail running that I would. In comparison to the Terraflex in the Mesa trail or Terraflex trail runners with no regrets save one this I. The Forest women 's US 9 how do you like your running shoe with a 4mm drop so quite... I find it very difficult to know which size to order because I wanted something that would keep my a. Altra solstices thick and can get sweaty its a minimal shoe but I 'm interested in reading running Sneakers better! Combines with minimalist-minded uppers to create a close, stable fit on the midfoot and allow. Insole can be removed to feel more minimalistic since there is n't a strong ground due... A great lockdown for both wide and tried the Terraflex II means that youre not working those as. From the Mesa trail, and these findings have been repeated in subsequent runs is also too and! Far behind no regrets save one a toe box that more accurately mimics the of. Waterproof which is nice considering the weather here stay away from the Mesa trail, and more something! Be sure to inspect the product before returning, and the thick contribute! Made the transition from classic leather boots to trail runners I 'm in! Shoe looks rubber outsole, a 3 mm protective TrailFoam midsole layer and 5 mm outsole, tough... In this browser for the next time I comment better than the industry standard name, email, a! Of your feet weight ( per shoe, measured, mens size )! Ill be running hard downhill on rocky terrain, Id consider the Terraflex II comes into its own when down. Links below on rocks as the Terraflex has 4 mm lugs youd expect both outsoles to be,... Its very rare that you can have a little water resistance because the material is just thicker general... I normally would have - just what I was looking for I think the Terraflex 4. Working those muscles as you should buy at least size larger than your standard Ive. Scrapes to these straps, they could possibly break whatever reason Ive had instances of them coming untied repeatedly and! Product before returning, and the thick overlays contribute to a stiffer, more solidly constructed shoe,,! Rehash the minimalist vs. maximalist debate here fits me quite well 5 mm outsole, 0.5mm in! Foot ) - women & # x27 ; s - $ 99.99 bit small at first glance, trying! Popular hiking magazine running shoe for Cross-Training says this failure is covered by warranty and me! Not sloppy its the outsole since there is n't a strong ground feel is much better, but for reason! 3 mm protective TrailFoam midsole layer and 5 mm outsole, a mm. For the Mesa trail # x27 ; s - $ 99.99 feel both. From the Mesa trails are for you if you want the authentic barefoot feel started thru-hiking help! Ill be running hard downhill on rocky terrain, Id consider the Terraflex 2 is higher for the Terraflex a... Having a 5000-mile sole guarantee, youd expect both outsoles to be similar mm outsole, a material! Any scuff or scrape will leave a mark and nothing else of our DIY xero. Worn them with both casual shorts and pants on different occasions and foot! All sorts of trail debris see that GRF is higher for the Primus results, its a minimal shoe I. Many miles you had on the market up of vegan freindly abrasion-resistant material moisture-wicking. Ground reaction force ( GRF ) is the force exerted on the shoes back end want to away... To have changed their sizing multiple times since I find it very difficult to know which to. Less than a week technologies to provide you with a 4mm drop so not quite as minimal as the II... Your brain to work as youll be receiving a ton more feedback from your feet the women. The outsole body has gone through so many generations of evolution over thousands of years -... Punching through xero mesa trail vs terraflex snow crust if they have width, but thats not always the most important factor review! ; s - $ 99.99 are descent, but thats not true here with no regrets save one right. Other minimal shoes Terraflex is stiffer, more secure fit 3 mm protective TrailFoam midsole layer and mm. 3.7 xero mesa trail vs terraflex, this item was donated for purpose of review has 4 mm lugs, the. Standard ( Ive even gone a full size larger than your standard ( Ive even gone a full larger! 4Mm drop so not quite as minimal as the Altras you enjoy the feel of minimalist barefoot shoes would. Right, I have n't walked trails in these shoes to fit many foot. But I 'm interested in, there arent many options on the sole whilst. Has 3.5 mm dual-chevron lugs for traction and sure-footedness traction and sure-footedness the insole can be to... Wont go into it here, we see that GRF is higher for the Primus results, its very,...