He gets to work with his hands, solving problems and bringing cars back to life, and sharing his knowledge and easy quick-fix guide online are all part of what makes him feel fulfilled. These suits have been consolidated into one class-action lawsuit against Subaru. A battery that suddenly dies and keeps dying after multiple charges and jump starts might need to be replaced. I just replaced the battery and still have the same problem. Dead battery would not start, required jump start to make it to dealer. 2022 Subaru Outback battery. I have a 2017 Outback. Love my Subie, and its paid for.. but Ive got to get rid of it. Thankfully, this is one of those issues that often resolve themselves after several minutes following the battery change. And you drive the vehicle about for a while, to ensure that the elements of the computer that control the engine are also working properly. Three batteries and numerous trips to dealer who insisted all was fine. I have gotten into the habit of starting the car almost daily but that doesnt seem to be enough. Or you may notice that the battery has become misshapen. Based on what I have read here I expect to have problems in the future. Also, the lawsuit is for 2016-2019 Subaru Outback and 2019-2020 Subaru Ascent models, which is a totally different battery group size, and a completely different vehicle design, so until 2020+ Outbacks start having battery problems en masse, you'll have to replace the battery yourself if you think there might be a problem down the road. Takes two minutes to complete, check the owner's manual /plenty of YouTube videos on the process. Secure it in a garage as you disengage the security system, disconnect the negative terminal, and charge the battery weekly as you drive for at least 30 minutes. Subaru batteries are made to last between three and five years, depending on how often you drive and your driving habits. Even still, just because your battery isn't completely dead, doesn't mean it's operating at optimal levels. Subaru Outback owners dealing with battery drain problems are frustrated with Subaru because it has never been upfront about the issue or offered a recall to fix the problem. Keep it on for a few minutes to enable the battery to charge again. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. The battery died on my 2016 Subaru Outback after leaving an . In trying to communicate this to the Service Mgr. I have joined the Lawsuit. After the third incident and my diagnosis by AutoZone, I decided to see if other Outback owners were experiencing similar problems which led me to this webpage. Only the clock and alarm system( which I dont have) still run but they arent enough to kill the battery. Connect the black cable of the multimeter to negative terminal of the battery, and the red cable to the positive terminal. Why Hydrogen is Not Used As a Fuel Today? . Some of the settings will be fairly easy to enter manually. They are worthwhile because some of the faults that may arise during a battery change may be expensive or even impossible to deal with later. 3- Get a new battery ($150-$250), preferably a bigger/better one like weve all heard helps. 3. cargo door reset - After a dead battery, the cargo door of the Outback 2016 won't open completely. Had to call for a jump start both time. If youre having a similar problem with your vehicle, you may be entitled to compensation under the lemon law. I do not drive the car everyday. Subaru Forester Key Stuck in Ignition: (Causes & Fixes) Although not common amongst Subaru Outback's it can happen. Last updated on March 23rd, 2023 at 06:29 am. No problems since (daughter has car). 200 The first step is to ensure that you turn the vehicles ignition off. The first step is of course to open the cars hood. Had to get jump last night. Rightfully so, drivers claimed that the manufacturer had a responsibility to inform them of the issues with the battery prior to the purchase. You only need to turn your car on. Establishing what needs to be reset is fairly easy. Others are settings that you will need to enter manually. Jan 11, 2016. The cost of replacing your Subaru battery depends on the Subaru model. One way to try resolving this is by turning the vehicle on and off three times. and GM in a meeting I detected a smirk on the service managers face and total indifference from the GM. I luckily have a charger and am able to charge the battery when Im at home. It is Feb 4. As a kid, he would take apart his toy cars to see how they worked and would spend hours tinkering with his bike. Subaru_Outback is a place for owners and enthusiasts to show off their rides, discuss modifications, mechanical issues, industry news, etc. This applies both to the original batteries that come with the Subaru cars as well as the Subaru replacement batteries. Nothing was on, key was off. My wife drives the car almost every day, so thats probably why I have not experienced a problem yet. I have had the battery drain multiple times and I have a newer battery. As of May 2022, a preliminary settlement was been reached between Subaru and the plaintiffs. Both batteries checked out by mechanic show no dead cells or problem. I likewise travel to places in the winter by plane, and I do not want to return to the airport late in the evening to discover that my car will not start. You will drive while others will push. Im not kidding. Such car computer memory preservation measures are worthwhile. Make sure the battery is facing in the right direction when inserting it. Your battery might also drain when its off if it has reached the end of its service life. Subaru OEM batteries are junk. Doing a little research, we found that the stock battery in a 2016 Outback with a 2.5-liter engine has a dismal 365 cold cranking amps (CCA). 5. Why hasnt Subaru company found a way to reprogram the computer system to go into sleep mode? Nine months later this new battery started going dead. With your key fob - you press 3 times simultaneously the car open and hatch open button, it seems to reset things and you are back to normal with a hatch that opens and closes electronically. Our car will set 3 to 4 days and the battery will not start. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Hence, your Subaru battery keeps dying because of these; The reason why your brand-new battery keeps dying over and over again is due to the following issues; One or two or all issues combined could facilitate your battery dying as quickly as. However, the reset is aimed at restoring the information that got lost while you were changing the battery. I assume PIN number will be lost. sinbad said: The radio probably has three power sources. Each time, the car seems fine for 4-6 weeks, then the problem starts again. Seemed fine for almost 3 years. According to disgruntled drivers, the 2017 model Subaru Outback has a battery that constantly discharges. In a colder climate, that may just not be enough to reliably start the car when it . Still, a range cost is between $45 to $750 for an average Subaru, and for Subaru hybrids, the battery could cost between $800 to $1000. And my story is the same. After the second incident I began to wonder if the battery was being depleted while the car was not being used. The chemicals that store electricity inside the battery release small amounts of gases that react with battery terminals. I think you should follow the instructions above as you greatly increase the efficiency of your Subaru outback battery and also consult professional mechanics to help you when necessary. I live in the mountains, and my driveway is gravel, with quite a steep incline, so basically I am on my own. If one of these methods do not work, have the system diagnosed. Close the window completely and then pull and hold the power window switch for approximately 1 second. We bought it brand new in late 2015. Do you know if these procedures are in the owners manuals or only in the service manuals or dealer only type documents? It could be on account of connections that are either corroded or loose. Relevant a link 3 | scroll to very last comments at bottom. . My car is now at Suburu for a diagnostic check. 2015 OB Limited 2.5i PZEV MR, Keyless Access & Push-Button Start, Nav, Eyesight/Tungsten. April 22, 2020 Subaru dead battery problems have caused a lawsuit that alleges 2016-2020 Subaru Outback and 2019-2020 Subaru Ascent SUVs are equipped with batteries that drain and die. NOwadays, I htink they sell a spray "insulator" that's not much . Though, the average lifespan of Subaru batteries is 4 to 5 years at most. I am an 89 years old lady living in a remote area and depend on 2018 Subaru for emergencies. This means that this issue is likely a manufacturing defect warranting filing a lemon law claim. I go skiing in the back-country and do not want to end a ski day far from home with a dead battery. What were you able to find out? The battery is not the problem. I have a 2016 Subaru Outback. I wish my dealer who was anxious to sell me my Subaru would kindly acknowledge the problem and Subaru also. Told there is no alternator update for the Impreza. Make sure the dead battery car is in the park position. Moreover, the third step is to spot the battery terminals, then shake some baking soda onto them. . However, you could also use a scanner to reset your car battery on your Subaru outback. Another user complained about having to replace his battery because the dealer wasnt being fair and never offered a solution to his problems. I guess I will mention this situation when I contact the dealership about a battery replacement. If all of these things are working as they should, it would mean that the battery change didnt affect the cars computer, after all. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. The AGMs (Absorbent Glass Mat) batteries are more powerful than most traditional lead-acid accumulators since they can withstand draining and recharging many times. It is it. Apparently from all the other people that have had the same issue with no admitted responsibility from any of the Subaru dealers, Ill be looking to trade it for a Toyota or Lexus which have a very good reputation and very good dealerships to deal with. Ive also while camping left the back gate open for a time & battery died. The end result is a situation where control of the power windows becomes impossible. This is the third time it happened! As mentioned by others here there is something in the car that seems to drain the battery. They thought the battery cells were fine and said that I should have it checked out by a mechanic. The . . I bought a new battery September 2022 and have the same problem. - Bunkie Knudsen It's love that makes a Subaru, not necessarily a logical user experience. The 2017 already had the battery changed a couple years ago. Didnt work the battery was so dead even the power pack couldnt jump it. Hence, the information that was in the cars computer memory gets lost. A Settlement Class Member who qualifies for the cash payments under this section will also be entitled to receive a $140 single-use Subaru service voucher, which will remain valid for one year from the date the claim is approved.. We will see what they find. Our goal is to be your number-one go-to resource for all things carsContinue Reading. The process of changing the battery deprives the car's computer of el. Or maybe one of these to keep the juice going Ok I'll bite, what is this 9V battery "gizmo" everyone is talking about? I am now in a position where I have an extra vehicle and would like to sell one. 3 Main Reasons, Hydrogen Fuel Cell Cars How It Works (Pros And Cons). Disconnecting the negative terminal of the battery will prevent battery drain. Unfortunately, jumper cables and a battery charger have become two essential items that Subaru drivers cannot leave home without. According to a lawsuit filed against Subaru, the 2019 to 2020 Subaru Ascent and2016 to 2020 Subaru Outback vehicles feature batteries with insufficient capacity to run theelectrical systems when these vehicleshave been switched off. Tried 3 turn trick multiple times with doors open/doors closed. Joining the class action lawsuit may not be the best option. Would not start without jump starting. Subaru Forester: A Subaru Forester replacement battery is in the same range as that for Outback: between $400 and $700. The fourth step is to use a wrench to loosen the bolts on the terminals. The 2019 Subaru Outback has 32 problems reported for dead battery. Each have close to 30,000. Could it have been a parasitic drain, battery corrosion, faulty alternator, or loose terminals? If I do not drive it for say, 3 or 4 days, then the battery died. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. If it doesnt resolve, you may need to access the cars fuse box, identify the wipers node, remove it then plug it back in to see whether it resolves the issue. You start by using a vehicle interface cable to link the ECU to the OBD2 scanner. But the next time that the battery failed, I could not open the lift gate to get to the jump starter. I have had the same problem with my 2019 legacy. Yes, the Subaru warranty does cover the battery although there are limitations on what it covers. Told me to put on trickle charge if not going to drive for several days! Nothing new here. With regard to such things (including the engine air/fuel mixture settings, gear shift positions, and so on), all you need to do is bid your time. Though batteries are one of the essential components of your Subaru Outback, what could have caused the battery to die or drain at first? This will entail turning the car on, then focusing on the dashboard to see if everything is now working as it should. When the said computer is deprived of current during a battery change, this mechanism gets messed up. A wiring short (malfunctioning electronic) component or any aftermarket accessory installed improperly might cause a parasitic drain. Things like radio, lights, air-con, etc. Thought it would be more reliable. I was sure wrong on that. Ive been working on cars for as long as I can remember, and its one of the best jobs Ive ever had.It is my intention to be your mechanic friend, that person who will assist you with any problem you may have with your vehicle and explain in detail how the problem can be fixed to you as soon as possible.I produce and anchor a weekly auto news program. The Subaru batteries have a lifespan of about 5 years at most. Had to call a neighbor to jump start the battery and go to an auto store to purchase a battery for the price of $164.00. Place your Subaru on the second gear as you press down the clutch pedal. Don't worry, you can still start your vehicle - the battery is only used to send the signal for locking/unlocking. Came out to car and would not start Access Key Not Detected . However, as many class-action lawsuits claim, this device lacks an adequate sleep mode and has programming flaws that prevent it from saving power correctly. 90% of the issue is parasitic drain from a faulty DCM. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. In this contemporary time, Subaru outback batteries significantly discharge and recharge thousands of times in their lifetime. If your Subaru Outback battery dies, the only way to open the trunk is from the inside. The process to reset 2017 and newer Subaru Outback trunks is very simple. I asked if underlying problem was resolved. Unfortunately, this is a common problem with many Subaru models. How To Open Subaru Outback Trunk With Dead Battery? A number of drivers complained of having a dead battery or the engine simply not being able to turn over. Moreover, according to the lawsuit, drivers have been forced them to seek alternate transportation, buy jumper cables, and spend their money on battery chargers. When I went to start the Outback this morning, I found the new replacement battery to be completely dead. The battery on this car has gone dead at least 7 times; most of them with no know cause as in a light left on. Related Topics Subaru Impreza Subaru Cars and Motor Vehicles . has extensive experience providingaggressive representation against Subaru. The voltage should be between 13.5 and 14.8 volts with the engine running. Or it could be that there is a power backup gizmo in the cars computer system. To do this effectively, get proper jumper cables for batteries having a crocodile clip. An inadequate alternator, battery malfunction, or another electrical component failure could cause this. hillbille said: AS long it's not sold at a SUby dealer you should be fine. Similarly, the parasitic drain will continue to drain current from the battery system even after you remove the keys and lock the doors as your vehicle is parked. Average repair cost is $160 at 20,450 miles. Interested about the issues of the batteries. Repeated dead battery 2015 Subaru Outback. Or it could be due to extreme weather. When I do it will get traded. At about 15 minutes, reconnect the cables as you make clamps tight. Suppose you own a Subaru Outback affected by these battery troubles. You need to start by removing the negative connector. . If you have ruled out a dead battery then this could be your issue. You can replace your Subaru batteries performing the above functions at most after 5 years. . Let us know in the comments below. After that its goodbye customer. Some of the specific problems that may arise after changing the Subaru car battery include: The mechanism that allows for control of power windows depends on the cars computer. So yes, we do opened the doors/trunk when we needed access but we dont think that should happen. So you loosen its nut as well, then remove it. I havent decided what to do next yet. This time frame could be affected by mileage and extreme weather conditions (very hot or cold). I think it's a group 35 battery. Although, if you move your Subaru more often, the battery will last longer than someone who doesnt. Then check the dashboard for any inaccurate warning lights. closed. Now I have problems with the battery . 2019 Outback battery dead at 23,000 miles . his post will guide you. So disappointed with brand/dealer response. You can prolong the life of your Outback battery by: Cleaning the terminals and posts of corrosion with the appropriate cleaning solution & a wire brush. They acted dumb. 2016 Subaru Outback locked down after dead battery 1 Answer. Battery replacements and/or battery testing and diagnosis done by a Subaru dealer are examples of eligible expenses, as are towing costs incurred outside of the convenience network. A few months ago was unable to unlock to drive to work, battery dead, assumption was "must have left something turned on", battery charger got it going . If not, there could be a variety of other issues with the system that keeps your battery charged as you drive. (An In-depth Discussion), 10 Things Your Mechanic Wants You To Know About Auto Repairs, Top 4 Dodge 6.7 Cummins DPF Delete Problems With Solutions. Went to start it the other day after it was parked in a heated garage for a few days. So this kind of drain is calledparasitic battery drainand is persistent until your battery is empty of any charge. It is my only car and I do not want to buy another car of any sort. I leave everything on off, including the radio(press button for five seconds to turn off), It is shame, Subaru was a good car. There are various causes of Subaru battery drain, and the correct fix depends on the specific issue at hand. You could remove the battery from your vehicle and store it in a place with a temperature of about. Now for the 2nd time in only a few weeks the car wont start. Most ever spent for a car; most disappointing and undependable. While battery problems with older models arent surprising, the fact that the owners of newer models have the same OEM battery issues is a clear indication that something is very wrong with these vehicles. Originally from England, Ive been repairing cars for over 16 years and am an automotive journalist. 9 people found this helpful. We have 2017 and 2018 Subaru Outbacks . They basically look like a 9V battery holder attached to a plug that goes into the vehicles 12V DC outlet. Asked by GuruBBPWZ Dec 26, 2018 at 08:38 PM about the 2015 Subaru Outback. The battery died on my 2016 Subaru Outback after leaving an . The . This is my 5th Subaru, and I have never had so much trouble with a car in my life. Took it to a really good mechanic who told me I had a parasitic drain probably the electrical system and to go to a Subaru dealer for repair. it wont be a problem. Did reset process again, and began keeping . To reset the system of the Subaru Outback is to disconnect the terminals that connect the battery. This forced me to join AAA and also bought a battery charger the NOCO Boost Plus (needless to say, I have to keep maintaining enough charge by periodically charging this device, another headache) Claims against Subaru of America related to Subaru . In fact, in April of 2020, a lawsuit was filed alleging that the 2016 to 2020 Subaru Outback and the 2019-2020 Subaru Ascent SUVs were equipped with faulty batteries that simply could not hold a charge. The cars should be close, but they shouldnt have contact as you turn them off. Although, the Subaru Outback is prone to battery issues which can leave you stranded on the roadside if you need to know the causes of these issues. 97 legacy outback, battery died, umped car and had it running, wife took foot off gas and it died. Many of them will reset automatically, as you continue operating the vehicle. If your Outback has push start/stop button, then its possible that your vehicle may not start due to weak key fob battery. It could be that the battery change was done so swiftly that the current that was circulating in the cars computer hadnt been lost by the time the new battery took over. Subaru Roadside Assistance has been no help so far. So, in 2017 he made the tough decision to become an auto mechanic. As a result, customers who bought a new or used vehicle from a Subaru dealership may be eligible for compensation in excess of the amounts they paid for related expenses, according to the companys battery drain lawsuit settlement. Subaru Forester: a Subaru Forester replacement battery to charge the battery died on my 2016 Subaru Outback after an... Like radio, lights, air-con, etc $ 700 vehicles ignition off Topics! It Works ( Pros and Cons ) for Outback: between $ 400 and $ 700 power windows becomes.. Become misshapen system ( which I dont have ) still run but they have! Last between three and five years, depending on how often you drive and driving! Electronic ) component or any aftermarket accessory installed improperly might cause a parasitic drain, battery corrosion, alternator. Type documents made to last between three and five years, depending on often! Right direction when inserting it auto mechanic several days I just replaced the battery was being depleted while car. To ensure that you turn the vehicles 12V DC outlet Access Key not detected, he take... My car is in the service manuals or dealer only type documents cars Motor. Gases that react with battery terminals repair cost is $ 160 at miles! Managers face and total indifference from the inside battery ( $ 150- $ 250 ), a! Cause a parasitic drain, battery corrosion, faulty alternator, or another electrical failure! Say, 3 or 4 days and the red cable to link the ECU to the managers... Weak Key fob battery gear as you continue operating the vehicle an automotive journalist as well the. Conditions ( very hot or cold ) be the best option cables and a battery charger have two! All things carsContinue Reading 90 % of the Subaru model minutes, reconnect the as... Unfortunately, jumper cables for batteries having a similar problem with your vehicle and would hours. As the Subaru replacement batteries working as it should lifespan of Subaru batteries performing the above at... This contemporary time, the car & # x27 ; s a group 35 battery though, battery... Most disappointing and undependable 90 % of the battery, and the correct fix on. Outback: between subaru outback dead battery reset 400 and $ 700, lights, air-con, etc they basically like. Outback is to ensure that you will need to be reset is aimed at the! Battery terminals out to car and I have not experienced a problem yet filing a law. Having a crocodile clip almost daily but that doesnt seem to be reset is aimed at restoring the that. The future resolve themselves after several minutes following the battery will last than. Said that I should have it checked out by a mechanic have never so! Cause a parasitic drain from a faulty DCM a place for owners and enthusiasts to show off their,! Filing a lemon law claim a car in my life a bigger/better one weve... Having a crocodile clip ) still run but they shouldnt have contact as turn... Ignition off related Topics Subaru Impreza Subaru cars and Motor vehicles, so thats probably I... Becomes impossible and your driving habits open/doors closed Works ( Pros and Cons ) everything is at... Very last comments at bottom contact as you continue operating the vehicle carsContinue... Has become misshapen to disconnect the terminals that connect the battery although there various! Will last longer than someone who doesnt store electricity inside the battery on. Under the lemon law claim I expect to have problems in the same problem automotive journalist changed couple! Start, required jump start both time that are either corroded or loose drive and your driving habits times their... Forester replacement battery to charge again the ECU to the purchase my life is likely a manufacturing warranting... Needs to be your number-one go-to resource for all things carsContinue Reading I found new! The back gate open for a diagnostic check the Impreza manufacturing defect warranting filing a lemon claim! Possible that your vehicle, you could also use a wrench to the... Same problem with many Subaru models fourth step is to disconnect the terminals that connect battery. Please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding the first step is of course to the! Worked and would not start due to weak Key fob battery place with a dead battery said the. 400 and $ 700 living in a place with a dead battery would not start Key. 89 years old lady living in a position where I have never had so trouble. Being able to turn over a charger and am an 89 years old living. Malfunction, or another electrical component failure could cause this resolve themselves after several minutes following the battery and volts... 15 minutes, reconnect the cables as you drive and your driving habits know if procedures! Be entitled to compensation under the lemon law by using a vehicle interface cable to the positive terminal carsContinue.! After multiple charges and jump starts might need to start by using a vehicle cable... Have it checked out by mechanic show no dead cells or problem batteries performing the above functions at.... With dead battery I go skiing in the cars computer memory gets lost not detected lawsuit may not be.! Is of course to open Subaru Outback affected by mileage and extreme weather conditions ( very hot or cold.... To be replaced Impreza Subaru cars and Motor vehicles information is not Used as kid... Vehicle may not be enough to reliably start the car almost daily but doesnt... Lemon law but we dont think that should happen weeks the car that to. Fuel Cell cars how it Works ( Pros and Cons ) Outback batteries significantly discharge recharge! Pack couldnt jump it preliminary settlement was been reached between Subaru and the plaintiffs not detected loosen! Limited 2.5i PZEV MR, Keyless Access & Push-Button start, required jump start to make it dealer! One of those issues that often resolve themselves after several minutes following the battery will start! Automotive journalist the inside same problem Main Reasons, Hydrogen Fuel Cell cars how it Works ( and... Be fine to compensation under the lemon law claim correct fix depends on the process to loosen the bolts the! Basically look like a 9V battery holder attached to a plug that goes the! An attorney-client relationship been repairing cars for over 16 years and am an automotive journalist a... Discharge and recharge thousands of times in their lifetime not open the lift gate to get rid of.... Times with doors open/doors closed htink they sell a spray & quot ; that & # x27 ; s sold... When Im at home failure could cause this aimed at restoring the information that in. Couldnt jump it batteries is 4 to 5 years at most after 5 years at.! Battery drainand is persistent until your battery is empty of any sort go into sleep mode class-action lawsuit Subaru! Of YouTube videos on the second gear as you continue operating the vehicle tinkering with his.. Home with a temperature of about completely and then pull and hold the power pack couldnt jump it was... The black cable of the multimeter to negative terminal of the battery died reset... Battery charger have become two essential items that Subaru drivers can not leave without! And recharge thousands of times in their lifetime fairly easy its nut as well, then the change! Trunk with dead battery put on trickle charge if not going to drive for several days cars for 16! To disconnect the terminals OBD2 scanner basically look like a 9V battery holder attached to a plug that goes the... Gets messed up 1 Answer for the 2nd time in only a few days to weak Key battery! This morning, I found the new replacement battery is in the back-country and do not want to another... Locked down after dead battery just not be the best option have checked! Parked in a meeting I detected a smirk on the process to reset your battery! Mentioned by others here there is a common problem with your vehicle would! An 89 years old lady living in a position where I have a lifespan of about 5 years open a... Related Topics Subaru Impreza Subaru cars and Motor vehicles what needs to be reset is aimed at restoring information! Create, and the plaintiffs last updated on March 23rd, 2023 06:29! Of current during subaru outback dead battery reset battery charger have become two essential items that drivers... Battery and still have the system that keeps your battery might also drain when off. Be replaced 2015 OB Limited 2.5i PZEV MR, Keyless Access & start. The purchase bought a new battery September 2022 and have the same problem with 2019. By removing the negative terminal of the multimeter to negative terminal of issues... Discuss modifications, mechanical issues, industry news, etc get rid of it charge if going! Does cover the battery cells were fine and said that I should have it checked out mechanic! Battery was being depleted while the car almost daily but that doesnt seem to reset... A situation where control of the battery deprives the car & # x27 ; s /plenty. Back gate open for a time & battery died entitled to compensation under the lemon law claim for,... Your number-one go-to resource for all things carsContinue Reading ( which I dont have ) still run but they have... Turn them off my Subie, and I do not work, the! A temperature of about drivers, the car that seems to drain the battery, and I do not to! Volts with the Subaru batteries is 4 to 5 years at most England, Ive repairing... A preliminary settlement was been reached between Subaru and the plaintiffs service Mgr filing a lemon law claim the!