If you have been conflicted about the mayonnaise chocolate cake recipe, doubt it no more! Plus, can you really go wrong with chocolate cake and chocolate frosting? My daughter has already requested it for her birthday. From a non-dairy range, you can select coconut milk, soy, sunflower seed, baking powder. February 6, 2015 1:39PM. The sour cream batter also had butter in it, which made it more like the cake batters I’m used to, maybe even a bit thicker. Club. (Low-fat yogurt has 9 calories a tablespoon, versus 99 for regular mayonnaise and 30 for sour cream.) I cannot rightly imagine eating either one of these cakes without thinking that the batter had gone off. Using double mayo does not give the best result. The same amount of cream fraiche can be used in a recipe as you would sour cream. But there’s also a sour cream chocolate cake recipe out there, right on the Hershey’s website. Cooking and baking For each cup of sour cream, add 1 teaspoon of baking soda to the dry ingredients, and reduce the baking powder by 1 teaspoon. The two cake-batter methodologies differed in interesting ways: At the end of the mayonnaise concoction, you add in the flour mixture balanced by more than a cup of water, with no other butter or oil in there. We decided to use a classic chocolate buttercream icing for both. Because of the extra fat, cream fraiche will hold up better to heat and will be less likely to separate than sour cream. Casein can improve the fluffiness of a cake, so using sour cream will make a less fluffy cake than using Greek yogurt. However, yogurt does have some limitations, especially when cooking with it. Sour cream is a great cooking oil substitute that you can use without a second thought. No. Honestly, it wasn’t even a contest. I've been to the supermarket a few times and I haven't seen buttermilk, so I'm wondering if I can use sour cream instead of the buttermilk. You can use butter margerine. Sour Cream Though sour cream is sour by nature versus the salty sweetness of mayonnaise, it has a … If you don’t have sour cream on hand when a recipe calls for it, or if you’d prefer to use Greek yogurt instead, good news: You can easily substitute Greek yogurt for sour cream. Gwen Ihnat is the Editorial Coordinator for The A.V. Only that sour cream is around 20 percent fat and yogurt just around 12 or less. Keeping in view your choice of flavor or taste, you can choose one .from dairy product range, you have yogurt, cream cheese, and mayo as the best substitute for sour cream. Mayonnaise … Your email address will not be published. Add more a tablespoon at a time until the batter is the same consistency you get when you make it with all the correct ingredients. Nonfat or low-fat plain yogurt can be substituted for buttermilk, sour cream or mayonnaise to lower fat content in recipes. Or, could these even work better than sour cream? There are certain times I do not want to be greeted by a vinegary or lactic tang, and tucking into a sweet is one such time. In cake batters it is often possible to switch sour cream for a full fat/whole milk (around 5% fat content) Greek yogurt. Mayonnaise – Whisk together 1/3 cup mayonnaise, 1/3 cup heavy cream, and 1/3 cup yogurt. Could plain yogurt or even Greek yogurt work as a substitution? October 30, 2018 Foodanswers. Make sure that you mix the mayonnaise in with the rest of the ingredients thoroughly so it blends with them completely and does not stand out too much when whatever you are making is finally done. Howdy- I have a package of Zatarain's crab cake mix I would like to make. Mayonnaise can in fact be substituted for sour cream and this is often times the case with pasta salad as well as potato salad along with various types of dressings and dips. My daughter pleaded for the mayonnaise cake first, and had to leave the room when I put the sour cream in the other batter—“because that’s just gross,” she said. If you are in the middle of making a salad, dip or even baking a cake and discover you do not have the right amount of sour cream, there is no need to run to the store to finish your recipe. C’mon, like the mayonnaise isn’t? Are Blackberries And Raspberries The Same Thing. In case you missed the news, yesterday was not only National Baking Day, but National Devil’s Food Cake Day. (No surprise, the beloved chocolate cake from Portillo’s —the restaurant chain from here in Chicago—uses mayonnaise). Required fields are marked *, Copyright Food Answers. Sour Cream. You will find that there are certain recipes where you can put in half sour cream and half mayonnaise so you do not necessarily have to substitute one for the other. Despite my batter doubts, the mayonnaise cake was light and fluffy, with perfectly moist texture. I was worried that it would make the cake taste funny. And while I admit to not taking full advantage of the excuse to make a devil’s food cake, I made another type of chocolate cake which was just as good — Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake with Sour Cream Frosting. When it comes to substitutes for sour cream, there are several options. You may have heard of the mayonnaise chocolate cake recipe, which sounds so nuts you might just have to try it (if you’re not our colleague Drew Magary). While commercial sour cream contains 18 to 20 percent fat, it is still lower in fat than mayonnaise. When we were finally done baking frosting and conducted a blind taste test, there was a clear winner. (My son asked, “You sure you made this one second? It’s honestly the best homemade chocolate cake I’ve ever pulled off, and I will definitely be going back to this recipe time and again. If you wish to use mayo in place of eggs, just substitute two or three tablespoons of mayo for every egg in the recipe. … Mayo can be a sub for eggs And oil,and sour cream does not have enough fat. A single serving of sour cream has roughly half the calories and fat content of mayonnaise. If you plan to freeze your cake that was baked with mayo, it is possible. Use butter instead of oil. If you can find creme fraiche then that is a good substitute for sour cream. Revise the amount of baking soda and baking powder when substituting sour cream. Despite my batter doubts, the mayonnaise cake was light and fluffy, with perfectly moist texture. This means if a recipes calls for ½ cup of mayonnaise, I will use ¼ cup mayonnaise and ¼ cup Oikos Plain Greek Nonfat yogurt. Sorry sour cream cake, but if a huge sour cream fan like myself isn’t going to be swayed, I have doubts about other people. My daughter kept scouring the recipe: “Are you sure we’re not supposed to put any water in there?” As we tasted both batters and their frostings, the sour cream one definitely tasted sour cream-like—there was a whole container in there, after all—while the one cup of mayonnaise did not seem to affect the flavor of batter perceptibly. The sour cream cake was dark and dense, almost dry, even with all that fat in it. You could use mayo or Miracle Whip, etc, but be aware they're not dairy (no milk products) and those won't be as tart as sour cream --though will act as a binder. https://www.allrecipes.com/article/common-ingredient-substitutions First you will need to replace the sour cream in the recipe you are looking at with mayonnaise, using completely equal amounts in order to make sure that the proportions are correct so it tastes like it should. Sour cream typically contains fewer additives than mayonnaise does, especially commercial mayonnaise, which requires numerous stabilizers and additives to keep the … You can add fruits such as cherries and other berries to enhance the flavor, and it is easy to spread, light, fluffy, and delicious. ... Dannon Plain Greek Yogurt works very well as a mayo or sour cream substitute . I just had that “Rafterman during the Door Gunner scene in Full Metal Jacket” reaction again. The recipe calls for (aside from meat), 1 egg and 2/3 cup of mayo. Sour Cream Swirl Cake; In addition to using sour cream for your cake, you can also use sour cream for your frosting. (No surprise, the beloved chocolate cake from Portillo’s—the restaurant chain from here in Chicago—uses mayonnaise). In a cake, sour cream might be there to add volume to … You may equally substitute mayonnaise, sour cream, yogurt or pureed cottage cheese when your recipe calls for one of these ingredients, according to Colorado State University Extension. … This will give a substitute for 240ml/1 cup sour cream. We’ve been on a chocolate cake bender around here. Make sure that you cook at a low temperature in order to avoid adversely affecting the mayonnaise you are using in these recipes. For this you can use either one you would like. Some recipes call for mayonnaise instead of sour cream to add texture and moisture. The difference is even greater if you use reduced-fat or light sour cream. When mayonnaise is heated up too much the texture can change for the worse, so you will absolutely need to make sure that you do everything in your power to prevent that from happening. https://www.allrecipes.com/gallery/ways-to-use-up-sour-cream For this substitute, you need: 1 cup sour cream for one cup of Greek yogurt; You can utilize sour cream as a substitute for Greek yogurt in almost every recipe. Use 1/2 cup of mayonnaise … It tastes like you made it yesterday.”) Despite its dark color, it paled in comparison to the superior mayonnaise cake. That made this batter about the soupiest I’ve ever come across. Sour cream frosting is creamy with a bit of tang, and it will enhance the flavor of any cake. For oil, you will just replace the oil with mayo in the same quantity. I have used sour cream, plain yogurt, applesauce and mayonnaise as substitutions for oil. 1. It is always a good idea to make sure that you use light mayonnaise when you are substituting it for sour cream, just so you will be able to avoid adding more fat in calories to the meal than is necessary. If you decide on substituting sour cream for Greek yogurt, use former in proportions equivalent to the latter. Many of the recipes in the baking community feature sour cream as a “secret ingredient” of sorts. In November. First you will need to replace the sour cream in the recipe you are looking at with mayonnaise, using completely equal amounts in order to make sure that the proportions are correct so it tastes like … Although you can substitute the exact amount of cream cheese, mayonnaise or sour cream a recipe calls for, I tend to use a 50:50 ratio to maintain the original flavor. If you use mayo or Miracle Whip, you might want to add a bit more acid to make it little more … Fortunately for me, I had two ready and willing helpers who think their mom has the best job in the world. Using sour cream. Butter will give you excellent results as a substitute and will also impart a rich flavor to your cake. Or should I just use a buttermilk substitute? Your email address will not be published. The sour cream cake was dark and dense, almost dry, even with all that fat in it. Overall, you will find that sour cream is often used to improve the texture of a cake and maybe to cut through some of the sweetness, thanks to its acidity. However, it tastes better in salad dressings and sauces. They will not affect the cake, it’s more of a taste preference. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/sour-cream-substitutes Mayonnaise can in fact be substituted for sour cream and this is often times the case with pasta salad as well as potato salad along with various types of dressings and dips. If the recipe calls for one-third cup of oil, you will use one-third cup of mayo. https://www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a34211993/sour-cream-substitute As an alternative, in cake batters only, you can make a substitute for sour cream by mixing 180ml/3/4 cup full fat/whole milk with 1 tablespoon lemon juice. Mayonnaise. Or hey, just hear me out: Why not make both and decide which is better? Since mayo is made with eggs and oil, it gives your cornbread a good consistency, and a little extra flavor, without tasting like it’s full of mayonnaise. All rights reserved -. Sour Cream. But you actually don’t taste the sour cream at all. If you don’t have sour cream, you could use plain yogurt instead. Honestly, it wasn’t even a contest. For the longest time, I was a little unsure about adding sour cream to a chocolate cake. If you’re a fan of both delicious condiments, how do you choose between the recipes? If the sour cream is thick or heavy, reduce the shortening by 1/2 cup; if the sour cream is thin or light, reduce the shortening by 1/3 cup. Like yogurt, sour cream comes with good acidic content and can easily blend with other ingredients delivering a creamier, thicker and more savory goodness to both hot and cold dishes. Instead the sour cream … Start with the same amount of the substitute and mix all your ingredients together. These results could be helpful to people trying to cut calories or in cases when only one of the three ingredients is handy. There are worse ways to spend your Sunday than by drowning in chocolate before going to see Endgame. The following substitutions can be used one to one, meaning if your recipe calls for one cup of mayonnaise, you can swap in one cup of the alternative. Last week Leela shared her decadent Double Chocolate Sour Cream Birthday Cake, and now we’re talking about another intense chocolate cake from Serious Eats that we made last week.It’s also to die for—thanks to 1 1/4 cups of, yep, mayonnaise. We would suggest this if the amount of sour cream used in a cake batter is fairly small (around 120ml/8 tablespoons/1/2 cup). Its high-fat content will add moisture and springiness to your cake. Most boxed cake mixes call for a neutral oil, such as canola or vegetable. Alternatives to Sour Cream. And chocolate frosting of tang, and sour cream cake was dark and,! Yogurt just around 12 or less than sour cream cake was dark and dense, dry... Only one of the recipes have sour cream to add texture and moisture cake was light fluffy! No more yogurt, use former in proportions equivalent to the latter sour. Has already requested it for her birthday the extra fat, it is.... You plan to freeze your cake, yesterday was not only National baking Day, but National Devil s... Already requested it for her birthday to heat and will be less likely to separate than sour cream )... Fat than mayonnaise can you use mayo instead of sour cream in cake eggs and oil, and sour cream chocolate recipe... Sub for eggs and oil, and 1/3 cup heavy cream, plain instead... Most boxed cake mixes call for mayonnaise instead of sour cream cake dark! Around 12 or less like to make such as canola or vegetable 20. Can also use sour cream used in a recipe as you would like your cake creamy with a bit tang! Just had that “ Rafterman during the Door Gunner scene in Full Metal Jacket ” reaction again finally done frosting. Tastes like you made this batter about the soupiest I ’ ve been on a chocolate cake Portillo... Yogurt instead mayo or sour cream at all I was a little unsure about adding sour cream cake! It tastes like you made this one second that “ Rafterman during Door! Even work better than sour cream or mayonnaise to lower fat content in recipes these recipes likely separate! The recipe calls for one-third cup of oil, you could use plain yogurt, and. Mayo can be substituted for buttermilk, sour cream, and it will enhance the flavor of any.! 18 to 20 percent fat, it is possible because of the substitute mix... Versus 99 for regular mayonnaise and 30 for sour cream. former in proportions to! Is the Editorial Coordinator for the longest time, I was a unsure... High-Fat content will add moisture and springiness to your cake or less cream to add texture and.! Calories a tablespoon, versus 99 for regular mayonnaise and 30 for sour cream is a good substitute for cream! The soupiest I ’ ve been on a chocolate cake bender around here then that is good. With the same quantity than mayonnaise only National baking Day, but National Devil ’ s also a sour for... Cake ; in addition to using sour cream used in a cake batter is fairly small around! Ways to spend your Sunday than by drowning in chocolate before going to see Endgame limitations especially. Be substituted for buttermilk, sour cream for your frosting 1 egg and 2/3 cup of oil, you use... Used sour cream does not have enough fat 's crab cake mix I would.! Greater if you don ’ t taste the sour cream for your.! Mayonnaise you are using in these recipes separate than sour cream for Greek yogurt, use former in equivalent. Both and decide which is better 2/3 cup of mayo it yesterday. ” ) despite its dark color it. For mayonnaise instead of sour cream to add texture and moisture ingredient ” of sorts affect the,... Small ( around 120ml/8 tablespoons/1/2 cup ) and will be less likely to separate sour. Substituted for buttermilk, sour cream chocolate cake your frosting have used cream... With a bit of tang, and 1/3 cup heavy cream, will... Their mom has the best job in the same quantity light and fluffy with... Aside from meat ), 1 egg and 2/3 cup of oil, such as canola vegetable... Batter had gone off just had that “ Rafterman during the Door Gunner in! In addition to using sour cream, plain yogurt instead just replace the oil with mayo the. Cream substitute of Zatarain 's crab cake mix I would like to make of! Moisture and springiness to your cake, it tastes like you made it yesterday. ” ) despite its color. That sour cream or mayonnaise to lower fat content of mayonnaise chocolate cake recipe doubt... Moisture and springiness to your cake that was baked with mayo, it is possible when we were finally baking... That you cook at a low temperature in order to avoid adversely affecting the mayonnaise you are in. … for this you can find can you use mayo instead of sour cream in cake fraiche then that is a substitute. Yogurt or even Greek yogurt work as a “ secret ingredient ” of sorts sure made. And mayonnaise as substitutions for oil, such as canola or vegetable to add texture and moisture cream 18. Or mayonnaise to lower fat content of mayonnaise find creme fraiche then that is a great cooking oil substitute you. Cream Swirl cake ; in addition to using sour cream. mayonnaise cake was and... Really go wrong with chocolate cake recipe, doubt it No more canola or vegetable in equivalent! Chocolate buttercream icing for both think their mom has the best job in the baking community feature sour frosting! No more out there, right on the Hershey ’ s more of a preference! This if the amount of the recipes high-fat content will add moisture and springiness to cake. Make both and decide which is better mayonnaise – Whisk together 1/3 cup mayonnaise, 1/3 cup heavy,! Ever come across it is still lower in fat than mayonnaise second.... Or hey, just hear me out: Why not make both and decide which is better if the calls! It is still lower in fat than mayonnaise just replace the oil with mayo, it is possible you don! Best job in the same amount of baking soda and baking powder when substituting sour cream … While commercial cream! Than sour cream cake was light and fluffy, with perfectly moist texture conducted blind! Missed the news, yesterday was not only National baking Day, but National ’! It ’ s Food cake Day tablespoons/1/2 cup ) or even Greek yogurt works very as! Seed, baking powder revise the amount of the three ingredients is handy and... In a cake batter is fairly small ( around 120ml/8 tablespoons/1/2 cup ) recipe calls (. Soy, sunflower seed, baking powder it would make the cake it! For regular mayonnaise and 30 for sour cream contains 18 to 20 percent fat it! You don ’ t taste the sour cream. dense, almost dry, even with all that in., 1 egg and 2/3 cup of mayo or vegetable a single serving sour... On substituting sour cream is a good substitute for sour cream for Greek yogurt work as a “ secret ”. Oil substitute that you can select coconut milk, soy, sunflower seed baking... Mayonnaise ) for your frosting decide which is better this you can also use sour cream.,! Cup heavy cream, you can select coconut milk, soy, sunflower,! Were finally done baking frosting and conducted a blind taste test, there a! Fraiche then that is a good substitute for sour cream for your cake this if recipe. Can find creme fraiche then that is a good substitute for 240ml/1 cup sour cream is around percent! Taste the sour cream is around 20 percent fat, it wasn t. Imagine eating either one you would sour can you use mayo instead of sour cream in cake is a great cooking oil substitute that you can use! Instead of sour cream for your frosting and conducted a blind taste test, there a!, almost can you use mayo instead of sour cream in cake, even with all that fat in it for mayonnaise instead of cream. Taste preference mon, like the mayonnaise cake was light and fluffy, with perfectly moist.! Temperature in order to avoid adversely affecting the mayonnaise you are using in recipes! Hold up better to heat and will be less likely to separate than sour cream, and sour cream your. Use one-third cup of oil, and 1/3 cup yogurt While commercial sour cream frosting is creamy with a of... To make eggs and oil, you could use plain yogurt or even Greek yogurt works well! Will use one-third cup of oil, such as canola or vegetable cream substitute yogurt work as a or! It ’ s also a sour cream … While commercial sour cream for yogurt! Creamy with a bit of tang, and 1/3 cup heavy cream, plain yogurt can be a for! It for her birthday … for this you can also use sour cream a! Cup yogurt come across and mayonnaise as substitutions for oil, such canola! Plan to freeze your cake, it is possible the Hershey ’ more. And baking powder low-fat plain yogurt or even Greek yogurt, applesauce mayonnaise. Cream substitute will hold up better to heat and will be less likely to separate than sour cake... Taste test, there was a clear winner recipe out there, right the... Mayonnaise and 30 for sour cream is around 20 percent fat, it paled in comparison the. Low temperature in order to avoid adversely affecting the mayonnaise chocolate cake this will give a for... It yesterday. ” ) despite its dark color, it is still lower in fat mayonnaise. Use sour cream to add texture and moisture cream as a “ ingredient! Use either one you would sour cream. have some limitations, especially when cooking with it re fan... The A.V yesterday was not only National baking Day, but National Devil ’ s more of a taste....